Black Butler (2014) Review: A Demon, a Mystery, and a Quest for Revenge

 

Black Butler (Original title: Kuroshitsuji) | 2014 | 1h 59m
Genre: Dark Fantasy / Action / Adventure / Crime / Drama / Fantasy / Family / Horror / Mystery | Country: Japan
Director: Kentarô Ohtani, Keiichi Satô | Writer: Yana Toboso
Cast: Hiro Mizushima, Ayame Gôriki, Yûka
IMDb: 6.1
My Rate: 6/10

A mysterious series of mummy cases forces Kiyohara, the Queen's Watchdog, to investigate. With Sebastian, a demon who serves as her butler, by her side, Kiyohara seeks not only to solve the mystery but also to avenge her family.

Warning:

Violence, sensual content, drugs, alcohol, strong language, nudity


What if the most powerful being standing beside you were not an angel or a loyal human companion, but a demon willing to serve your every command? Black Butler (2014), adapted from Yana Toboso's manga of the same title, explores this intriguing idea by presenting a demon's greatest strength not through something purely frightening or evil, but through his ability to use his extraordinary powers exactly as the situation demands.

The story begins with a series of mysterious incidents in which politicians are being turned into mummies. The unusual cases attract the attention of the police and eventually reach the Queen, who orders her Watchdog to investigate. Kiyohara, one of the Queen's Watchdogs, takes on the case with the help of Sebastian, her loyal servant who is actually a demon.

Kiyohara is the heir to the Genpou family. After her family is murdered by an unknown person, she disguises herself as a boy so she can reclaim control of the family business. Alongside Sebastian, she sets out to investigate the mysterious incidents while pursuing her own desire for revenge. The investigation takes her into a dangerous adventure and gradually reveals an unexpected mystery. With time running out before the drug can be used to incapacitate the city, Kiyohara must uncover the truth and avenge her family before it is too late.

The film opens with a narration explaining the world in which the story takes place, including the political situation, the threats that need investigating, and the identity and role of the Watchdog. The information is presented clearly enough to establish the story's foundations. This is particularly helpful for viewers who have never read the manga or watched the anime, as they can understand the basic premise without needing prior knowledge of the original material.

The first major incident wastes no time introducing the danger. A supporting character suffers an accident and turns into a mummy, immediately establishing the tension while introducing one of the central mysteries that connects the events throughout the film.

Another conflict emerges through Shiori, the main character, who has a personal revenge to pursue. Unfortunately, this internal struggle never feels particularly strong. Her emotional turmoil receives little attention and rarely becomes a major focus of the story. Although revenge is supposed to be one of her primary motivations, the emotional weight behind it does not come through as convincingly as it should.

This may have something to do with the way Shiori herself is portrayed. It is not that Ayame Goriki delivers a poor performance. Rather, the character seems to lack the presence that should define her. Shiori is introduced as an heir who successfully leads a company at a young age and possesses a strong determination to avenge her family. Yet that confidence and authority do not fully translate through her eyes, facial expressions, or body language. The character's supposed strength is there in the story, but it is not always visible in her performance.

Sebastian, on the other hand, feels considerably more commanding. His fight sequences are among the film's most entertaining moments. His portrayal effectively communicates what makes him a demon: his extraordinary speed, his apparent inability to die or sustain injuries, and the confident way he carries himself. There is something captivating about his presence that makes it easy for viewers to become fascinated by him. In many ways, Sebastian becomes the film's strongest attraction.

The ending is presented quite well, with a small twist involving Shiori's past. Although the main case is resolved, several aspects of the story remain open. This is understandable to some extent because the film does not attempt to conclude the entire story from the manga; it only adapts a portion of it. On the positive side, the characters show noticeable development as the story progresses.

The technical aspects are also handled reasonably well. The detail shots, camera movements, and colour composition support the atmosphere, while the music and sound effects feel distinctive without being out of place. The visual effects are another strength, particularly the depiction of blood coming from the nose, ears, and eyes, as well as the appearance of the mummified bodies. These details help make the disturbing incidents feel more convincing.

One particularly memorable scene involves a group of politicians who become test subjects in an experiment. They are given a drug that gradually turns them into mummies. Panic spreads as blood begins flowing from their mouths, ears, and eyes, making death seem imminent. When an antidote is finally presented, they immediately push and fight one another to get it, showing little concern for the safety of the people around them.

The scene reflects one of the most basic aspects of human nature: the instinct to survive. Our first impulse is often to save ourselves, and in many ways, that reaction is understandable. Interestingly, the film also presents the opposite response through Kiyohara, who is willing to sacrifice herself to save someone else. Both reactions are part of being human. What ultimately matters is the choice we make when faced with a situation that tests our willingness to put others before ourselves.

The dialogue, "Even demons are not the only ones blessed by God," adds another interesting dimension to the film's portrayal of morality and the supernatural. It suggests that goodness and the capacity to protect others cannot simply be determined by appearances or by whether someone belongs to the human or demonic world.

Ultimately, Black Butler (2014) offers an intriguing fictional world and finds much of its appeal in Sebastian's strong characterisation. However, that strength is not fully balanced by the protagonist, who should have been at the centre of the story's emotional conflict. Although some parts remain unresolved, the film's happy ending provides a satisfying sense of closure to its main conflict, and I would consider it worth watching, particularly for viewers who enjoy a combination of mystery, supernatural elements, action, and a demon whose presence is difficult to ignore. Beyond the supernatural spectacle, the film also leaves us with a question about human nature: when survival is at stake, will we choose to save ourselves at any cost, or will we still find the courage to protect someone else?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments