Under
the Tree | 2008 | 1h 44m
Genre: Drama | Country: Indonesia
Director: Garin Nugroho | Writers: Aramantono, Garin Nugroho
Cast: Marcella Zalianty, Ayu Laksmi, Nadia Saphira
IMDb: 6.8
My Rating: 7/10
On the magical island of Bali, three women—Maharani, Dewi, and Nian—face their own struggles while searching for answers to the deeper questions of life, family, and belonging.
Warning:
None
What if the biggest problems in our lives are not really about ourselves, but about the people we cannot stop being connected to?
That
is the feeling I get from Under the Tree (2008), also known as Di
Bawah Pohon. The film follows three women with very different lives, yet
somehow their stories keep circling around the same emotional subject: the
complicated bond between parents and children. Set in Bali and directed by
Garin Nugroho, the film uses symbolism, culture, and philosophical ideas to
tell its stories in a way that is beautiful but not always easy to understand.
The
first story belongs to Maharani (Marcella Zalianty), who comes from Jakarta to
Bali in search of her biological mother. She is an adopted child and has always
wanted to know where she came from. According to a fortune teller, her
biological mother was a dancer, which leads Maharani to Kaler, a dance teacher.
Her search gradually pulls her into various complicated situations, including a
case involving child trafficking.
Then
there is Dewi (Ayu Laksmi), a radio announcer who is pregnant. Her husband has
not returned home, leaving the people around her wondering what has happened.
But Dewi has a much heavier problem that she keeps largely to herself: doctors
have told her that the baby she is carrying has a disability and may not live
long after birth.
Now
she has to make an incredibly painful decision. Should she continue the
pregnancy and accept all of the risks that come with it, or should she have an
abortion? What makes the situation even harder is that she has not yet told her
husband.
The
third story follows Nian (Nadia Saphira), a young actress who escapes to Bali
to avoid conflict with her father. Nian never feels that she has had the kind
of father figure she needs, so when she meets Darma, an older painter, she
immediately feels that she has finally found the father she has been looking
for.
Nian
keeps following Darma everywhere, even when her presence starts to bother him.
Her emotional state becomes even worse after her father is implicated in a
corruption case.
Three
women. Three different problems. Yet the emotional thread connecting them is
surprisingly similar. Each story is, in one way or another, about the bond
between a parent and a child, and about the emotional consequences when that
bond becomes complicated, broken, or impossible to understand.
That
is probably the main reason I find Under the Tree so interesting.
Garin
Nugroho has a very recognizable way of telling stories, and this film is full
of symbols. I personally like that aspect because it gives the film an artistic
quality. At the same time, I also understand why some viewers may struggle with
it. The film does not always explain the meaning of every symbol directly. It
asks the audience to pay attention and interpret what they are seeing.
For
me, that makes Under the Tree the kind of film that cannot always be
watched casually while doing something else. There are moments when I feel that
I need to stop and think about what a particular image, conversation, or action
is trying to say.
Among
the three stories, I find Dewi's the easiest to understand. Her dilemma is
presented clearly, and I can follow the emotional process she goes through from
one scene to another. Her story feels like one continuous emotional journey, so
the scenes connect naturally.
Maharani
and Nian's stories feel more fragmented to me. Their plots sometimes seem to
move so quickly from one situation to another that I feel as though pieces of
the story are being separated before I have fully absorbed them. Still, even
though these stories can be confusing at times, I think they contain meaningful
ideas.
That
contrast is actually one of the interesting things about the film. I may not
understand every detail immediately, but I can still feel that there is
something deeper underneath the surface.
The
technical presentation also contributes greatly to that experience. I really
like the music and sound effects in this film. They feel original and are
carefully matched to each situation. The camera movement and visual details are
also handled beautifully. There is a great deal of attention given to the
images, and the film allows us to enjoy Bali not only as a setting, but also as
part of the story's cultural identity.
Watching
the film, I also get a strong sense of Balinese culture through the traditions,
atmosphere, and visual elements presented throughout the story. For me, that is
one of the film's strengths. It becomes more than a drama about three women. It
also gives viewers a glimpse of Bali through an artistic and philosophical
lens.
I
think this is particularly valuable for films that want to introduce local
culture to a wider audience. Bali is not simply there to make the film look
beautiful. Its cultural elements become part of the way the characters and
their problems are understood.
But
there is one scene that stayed with me more than the others, and it belongs to
Dewi.
Dewi
is overwhelmed by the decision she has to make about her unborn child. She
sings about life and death while eating an egg. The egg becomes a symbol of the
fetus she is carrying, and as her singing becomes more frustrated, she
repeatedly tears apart the egg in her hands.
I
found this scene disturbing and beautiful at the same time.
The
symbolism is not subtle, but it works. We can feel Dewi's confusion, fear,
anger, and helplessness all at once. Ayu Laksmi's acting makes the scene even
more powerful because her facial expression and voice make the emotional
conflict feel very real.
For
me, this is where the film's use of symbolism works best. It does not simply
tell us that Dewi is struggling. It gives that struggle a physical form that we
can see.
The
dialogue, “My beloved child, you were born from many different stories,” also
stays with me because it captures something central to the film. Children do
not exist separately from the stories of the adults around them. They become
part of family histories, expectations, mistakes, hopes, and wounds that
existed long before they were born.
And
perhaps that is what makes the three stories feel connected even though the
women themselves have very different lives.
We
often talk about family as though it automatically means comfort and belonging.
But family can also be where some of our deepest emotional conflicts begin. A
child may spend years searching for a biological parent. A mother may have to
make an unbearable decision because of her unborn child. A daughter may run
away from her father and look for another person to fill the role she feels she
is missing.
None
of these problems are simple.
What
I appreciate about Under the Tree is that it does not try to make these
emotional questions feel easy. The film leaves room for uncertainty,
discomfort, and interpretation. I do not always understand every symbol or
every movement in the story, but perhaps that is part of the experience.
After
watching it, I found myself thinking about how deeply our relationships with
our parents can shape the people we become. Sometimes we spend years looking
for answers from them. Sometimes we spend years trying to escape them.
Sometimes we become parents ourselves and realize that there are no perfect
decisions, only difficult ones.
The
film's title suddenly feels meaningful to me as well. A tree can be a place
where people gather, rest, hide, or search for shelter. But it is also
connected to roots—something we cannot always see, yet something that
determines how a tree grows.
Perhaps
family is like that too.
We
may move far away. We may build completely different lives. We may even try to
forget where we came from. But our roots can still influence us in ways we do
not always recognize.
That
is why I find Under the Tree (2008) worth watching, especially for
viewers who enjoy films with philosophical themes, symbolism, and deeper
emotional questions. It may not be the easiest film to understand, but I think
its complexity is part of what makes it memorable.
And
perhaps the question I took away from it is not about whether we can escape our
family stories, but something more personal: how much of the person we are
today was shaped by the people who raised us—and how much of our own story are
we still trying to rewrite?
Cliffhanger
Worth
Watching
(Aluna
Uwie)
Had
been published in Alunauwie.com
"This
article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English
for international readers."
Read also:
Aruna & Her Palate (2018) Review
The Photograph (2007) Review
Biola Tak Berdawai (2003) Review

0 Comments