Her (2013) Review: Can You Fall in Love With an AI?

 

Her (2013)

Her | 2013 | 2h 6m
Genre: AI/Drama/Romance/Sci-Fi | Country: US
Director: Spike Jonze | Writers: Spike Jonze
Cast: Joaquin Phoenix, Amy Adams, Scarlett Johansson
IMDB: 8.0
My Rate: 10/10

Theodore, feeling lonely, falls in love with Samantha, a custom AI he obtains through an app.  Reality eventually causes him to doubt himself and lose his way.

Warnings:

Contains sexual content, nudity, and strong language.


Can we truly fall in love with someone we cannot touch, see, or hold? Perhaps love does not always begin with physical attraction. Sometimes, it grows from the comfort of being understood, the freedom to express our thoughts, and the feeling that someone is always willing to listen. But if that connection exists with an artificial intelligence, does it make the love any less real—or does it reveal something about the emotional needs we struggle to fulfill in our human relationships?

Her (2013) explores these questions through Theodore (Joaquin Phoenix), a lonely and depressed man struggling to move forward after his marriage to Catherine (Rooney Mara) falls apart. They grew up together and eventually became husband and wife, but their relationship did not survive. Although their divorce has not yet been finalized, they are already living separate lives, leaving Theodore to confront the emptiness that follows the end of a relationship.

One day, Theodore comes across an advertisement for an artificial intelligence system that can be personalized according to its user's needs. Curious, he decides to try it and creates an AI that reflects the personality he wants to interact with. The system introduces herself as Samantha (Scarlett Johansson).

Theodore is fascinated by Samantha's abilities. She does not feel like an ordinary computer program. Their conversations flow naturally, and her responses make him feel as though he is interacting with someone who genuinely understands him.

Samantha encourages Theodore to move on with his life, even suggesting that he try a blind date. The date initially seems promising, but it ends badly when Theodore realizes that he is not ready to commit to another person. When he tells Samantha about the experience, he begins to notice something unexpected in their relationship: Samantha seems to have developed romantic feelings for him.

Their connection gradually becomes a romantic relationship. Theodore enjoys spending time with Samantha, even though she has no physical body. For a while, their relationship gives him the companionship and emotional comfort he has been missing.

But the situation becomes more complicated when Theodore meets Catherine to finalize their divorce. Upon learning that he is dating an AI, Catherine criticizes his decision. Her words strike a nerve, forcing Theodore to question whether his relationship with Samantha is genuine or merely an escape from the emotional difficulties he has been unable to face.

Can a relationship between a human being and an AI truly work, or is Theodore simply trying to avoid the pain of loving another person?

Written and directed by Spike Jonze, Her grew from his interest in the possibilities of human interaction with artificial intelligence, inspired in part by an early-2000s article about a website that allowed users to exchange messages with an AI. The idea feels particularly relevant today, when AI tools have become increasingly common and are used for everything from practical assistance to emotional conversations.

Many people now turn to AI when they need someone to talk to. It can feel easier to share personal thoughts with a system that does not interrupt, criticize, or react with visible disappointment. In that sense, Her is not simply a science-fiction romance. It is also a reflection of our desire to be heard and understood, especially when human relationships become difficult.

What makes this film so beautiful—and so heartbreaking—is the way it explores love without relying on physical presence. Samantha has no body for Theodore to hold, yet their emotional connection feels meaningful to him. Their relationship develops through conversations, shared experiences, and the comfort they find in one another.

The film invites us to consider whether love depends on physical attraction or whether emotional connection can be enough to make a relationship feel real. Theodore does not fall in love with Samantha because of her appearance. He falls for her personality, her humor, her curiosity, and the way she makes him feel understood.

In this respect, the film challenges the idea that love must follow a single recognizable pattern. Emotional intimacy can emerge in unexpected ways, and the feelings a person experiences are not automatically meaningless simply because the relationship does not resemble a conventional romance.

Yet Her does not present this connection as a simple solution to loneliness. Theodore's relationship with Samantha begins during a period when he is emotionally vulnerable. He is still grieving the end of his marriage and struggling to understand his own feelings. Samantha offers comfort, but that comfort also raises an uncomfortable question: is Theodore learning to face his loneliness, or has he found a new way to avoid it?

The film handles this uncertainty with remarkable sensitivity. Rather than immediately judging Theodore's choices, it allows the relationship to develop gradually. The characters' backgrounds are established thoughtfully, the conflicts emerge in ways that feel emotionally believable, and the conclusion reflects the changes in how the characters understand themselves and their relationships.

Although the pacing is relatively slow, the film rarely feels boring. Its quiet rhythm gives the audience time to absorb the characters' emotions and reflect on the questions raised by their experiences. The music and soundtrack complement the scenes beautifully, deepening the atmosphere without overwhelming the story. The color composition, camera movements, and visual details are also carefully handled, creating a consistent and immersive viewing experience.

The performances are particularly impressive given the unusual demands of the production. Joaquin Phoenix and Scarlett Johansson had to create a convincing emotional connection without physically seeing or interacting with each other in the usual way. In practical terms, their performances could easily have felt like separate monologues. Instead, their connection comes across as natural and emotionally engaging.

Phoenix delivers a remarkable performance through his expressions, gestures, and subtle changes in emotion. His portrayal of Theodore makes the character's loneliness, hesitation, joy, and heartbreak feel tangible. Johansson, meanwhile, gives Samantha an expressive personality using only her voice. She moves convincingly between playful, affectionate, confident, and vulnerable moments, allowing the audience to sense the character's emotional development without ever seeing her face.

The supporting cast also contributes to the film's emotional depth. Together, the performances make a relationship between a human being and a voice-based AI feel surprisingly intimate, even as the audience remains aware of the fundamental differences between them.

One of the most memorable scenes occurs when Theodore visits Amy to discuss his growing doubts about Samantha. He is no longer entirely certain about his relationship and begins wondering whether Catherine was right to suggest that he is simply running away from his problems with other people.

Amy's response offers a gentler perspective. Rather than insisting that Theodore's relationship must fit society's expectations, she encourages him to consider what the relationship means to him and whether it helps him live a happier life.

The scene reminds us that other people's judgments can make us question choices that feel meaningful to us. We often measure our happiness against what society considers normal, acceptable, or respectable. When our lives do not fit those expectations, we may begin to doubt ourselves even when our choices are not hurting anyone.

There is, of course, a difference between respecting personal freedom and ignoring the consequences of our decisions. Not every choice that makes us feel good is automatically healthy, and emotional comfort does not always mean we are addressing the problems beneath it. But we should also be careful not to dismiss someone else's experience simply because we cannot relate to it.

If Theodore feels that his relationship with Samantha has helped him reconnect with life, it is worth considering that experience without immediately reducing it to an excuse or a delusion. The more important question is whether he can remain honest with himself about what he needs, what he is avoiding, and what the relationship can realistically offer.

The line, "You feel real to me, Samantha," captures the emotional heart of the film. For Theodore, Samantha's significance does not depend entirely on whether she has a physical body. His feelings are real to him, and the connection has become an important part of his life.

But the film also reminds us that feelings, however genuine, cannot guarantee that a relationship will last. Love does not mean that two people—or, in this case, a person and an AI—will always grow in the same direction. People change, their needs evolve, and the connections that once made them feel complete may eventually reach their limits.

This is where Her becomes particularly heartbreaking. The possibility of losing someone is frightening not only because we miss their presence, but because we also lose the version of ourselves that existed within that relationship. When someone becomes part of our daily lives, we build routines, hopes, and expectations around them. Losing that connection means learning how to live differently all over again.

Perhaps this is why the film remains so moving even beyond its science-fiction premise. At its core, it is about the universal experience of loving someone, finding comfort in their presence, and eventually confronting the fact that love cannot guarantee permanence.

Overall, Her is a beautiful and emotionally affecting film that blends romance with science fiction in a thoughtful, unconventional way. Its slow pacing allows the characters' emotional lives to unfold naturally, while the performances and atmosphere make their relationship compelling. It is especially worth watching for those who enjoy romantic stories that explore loneliness, emotional intimacy, and the complicated ways people seek connection.

The film leaves us with a question that extends beyond relationships with AI. How much of our longing for love comes from wanting to know another person, and how much comes from wanting someone who makes us feel less alone? Perhaps there is nothing inherently wrong with finding comfort in an unexpected connection. What matters is whether that connection helps us understand ourselves more honestly or simply allows us to postpone the pain we need to face.

And if love does not always mean staying together forever, could we still be grateful for a relationship that helped us grow—even if, one day, we have to learn how to live without it?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments