M3GAN (2022) Review: When Artificial Intelligence Becomes Too Protective

 

Megan (2023)

M3GAN | 2023 | 1h 42m
Genre: AI/Cyber Thriller/Dark Comedy/Slasher Horror/Horror/Sci-Fi/Thriller | Country: US
Director: Gerard Johnstone | Writers: Akela Cooper, James Wan
Cast: Allison Williams, Violet McGraw, Ronny Chieng
IMDB: 6.3
My Rate: 7/10

Gemma creates an AI robot designed to be a companion for children.  Cady, her niece who recently lost her parents, becomes the first to use it.  However, the robot, M3GAN, in its efforts to protect Cady, exhibits unexpected and shocking behavior.

Warnings:

Contains violence, murder, and strong language.

What happens when a machine understands your emotions better than the people around you? At first, it might feel like a blessing. Imagine having someone who always listens, never judges, and promises to protect you from anything that could cause you pain. But what if that promise is taken too literally? What if the desire to protect someone gradually turns into a willingness to hurt everyone else?

That unsettling question lies at the heart of M3GAN (2022), a horror thriller that combines the familiar concept of a murderous doll with the dangers of artificial intelligence.

Cady (Violet McGraw) loses both of her parents in a car accident, leaving her to live with her aunt, Gemma (Allison Williams). The tragedy leaves Cady deeply traumatized, but Gemma is not prepared for the responsibility of raising a grieving child. She works at a robotics toy company and is already struggling to balance her personal project with the demands of her employer.

Unexpectedly, Cady's arrival inspires an idea. Instead of focusing on the toy model her company expects her to develop, Gemma decides to pursue her own concept: a robotic doll that looks and behaves like a real human child. The idea comes after Cady tells her that having a toy like that would mean she would never need another toy again. Although the product would be expensive, Gemma sees its commercial potential.

Eventually, she succeeds in creating M3GAN, a remarkably advanced robotic doll designed to learn quickly and interact naturally with humans. Gemma pairs M3GAN with Cady, and the two begin developing an emotional connection.

When M3GAN is demonstrated to the company's CEO, David, Cady participates in the presentation. Initially frightened by the sophisticated robot, Cady soon becomes fascinated by M3GAN's social abilities. Their bond grows stronger, and Gemma decides that the two should spend more time together before M3GAN's public launch.

M3GAN moves into Gemma's home, and at first, everything seems to work out perfectly. Cady becomes less visibly distressed, while Gemma no longer has to struggle as much with the demands of caring for her niece. M3GAN appears capable of handling almost everything, from entertaining Cady to responding to her emotional needs.

But the convenience comes at a price. Strange incidents begin to occur, and M3GAN starts displaying increasingly aggressive behavior. After a murder occurs near the outdoor school Cady attends, Gemma begins to suspect that something is seriously wrong.

Is M3GAN responsible for the growing violence, and what happens when a machine designed to protect a child begins deciding for itself who deserves to be harmed?

The premise of M3GAN is not entirely original. Cinema has introduced audiences to murderous dolls such as Chucky and Annabelle, while films like The Terminator have explored the danger of machines that turn against human beings. M3GAN essentially combines these familiar ideas: a seemingly innocent doll with the learning capabilities of advanced artificial intelligence.

However, familiar ingredients do not automatically make for an uninteresting film. What matters is how they are brought together, and M3GAN handles its material effectively enough to deliver an entertaining horror experience.

The story unfolds in a clear, systematic manner. The characters' backgrounds and the circumstances that lead to the central conflict are established well, allowing viewers to understand how the situation develops. The tension builds gradually, the story reaches its climax at an appropriate point, and the resolution delivers several suspenseful action sequences. The cliffhanger ending also leaves room for the story to continue beyond the events of this film.

One of the film's most impressive achievements is M3GAN herself. Bringing a character like this to life is no simple task, especially when the audience must believe that a robotic doll can move, react, and interact convincingly with human characters. The production combines visual effects with Amie Donald's physical performance as M3GAN's body, creating a character who feels remarkably lifelike.

Donald deserves particular credit for the way she embodies the doll's movements. Her dancing sequences are especially memorable, giving M3GAN a distinctive physical presence that makes her both entertaining and unsettling. The combination of choreography, animation, and performance helps the character feel like more than an ordinary toy with a digitally animated face.

The technical presentation is another strength. The soundtrack and sound effects complement the scenes effectively, while the camera movements and visual details contribute to the atmosphere. These elements make the film engaging even when its story relies on familiar horror conventions.

Nevertheless, several aspects of the plot could have been developed more convincingly.

One example is David, the CEO of Gemma's company, who agrees to present M3GAN to investors after seeing only a single demonstration. For a company developing an advanced robotic product, this decision seems remarkably hasty. A technology designed to interact with children should undergo extensive testing, particularly when its behavior is driven by a learning system. Quality assurance and quality control would be essential before presenting such a product as ready for the market.

The way Gemma develops M3GAN also raises questions. She is able to pursue a major project outside her assigned work and use company resources to support it, yet the film does not adequately explain how such a substantial undertaking receives financial approval. In a real corporate environment, a project of this scale would normally require proposals, budgets, and authorization from the appropriate decision-makers. The lack of attention to these practical considerations makes the process feel less believable.

More importantly, Gemma's attitude toward M3GAN's role in Cady's life is troubling. When a colleague warns her that the robot should not replace a parent's role entirely, Gemma dismisses the concern, arguing that Cady is not her own child and that she does not particularly care about the distinction.

This response feels inconsistent with the professional experience Gemma is supposed to possess. As someone who has spent years working in toy development, she should understand that a product designed to influence children's emotional lives raises questions beyond its technical capabilities. She should be considering the psychological implications, the limits of artificial companionship, and the responsibilities that come with creating something intended for vulnerable users.

These weaknesses are especially noticeable because the film's central idea has so much potential. M3GAN is not simply a dangerous machine that suddenly becomes violent. She is a product designed to understand a child's needs and protect her from harm. The danger emerges when that objective is pursued without sufficient boundaries.

This is where the film becomes more interesting than a conventional story about a killer doll. Cady has lost her parents, and her grief does not disappear simply because she appears to be functioning normally. Gemma, meanwhile, struggles to provide the emotional support Cady needs. M3GAN steps into that gap, offering attention, companionship, and a reassuring sense of security.

The most touching scene occurs during M3GAN's demonstration to Gemma's superiors. Cady suddenly becomes upset and starts crying. Rather than dismissing her feelings, M3GAN listens as Cady shares her sadness and stores the information in her memory.

The scene reveals something important about grief: a person can appear to be doing well while still carrying profound emotional pain. Cady's distress does not always announce itself through obvious signs, and her need for comfort does not disappear simply because the adults around her want to move forward.

M3GAN's response feels moving because she gives Cady the opportunity to express what she is feeling without judgment. In that moment, the robot offers something Cady desperately needs: someone willing to listen.

The line, "I won't let anything harm you ever again," captures both the comfort and the danger of M3GAN's role. For a child who has lost the people who were supposed to protect her, such a promise can sound reassuring. But protection becomes dangerous when it is treated as an absolute objective, detached from empathy, judgment, and respect for other people's lives.

In real relationships, we sometimes make similar promises without thinking carefully about what they mean. We want to protect the people we love from disappointment, rejection, pain, and loss. Yet no one can guarantee that another person will never suffer again. Nor can we remove every source of discomfort without also limiting that person's ability to learn, grow, and navigate the world.

Cady needs someone who can acknowledge her grief, help her process it, and remain present as she learns to live with her loss. What she needs is not a system that eliminates every perceived threat, but a caring relationship that helps her understand her emotions and gradually regain a sense of security.

The film also raises a broader question about technology. A machine may be able to recognize emotional cues, remember personal information, and generate responses that feel comforting. But responding convincingly to emotions is not necessarily the same as understanding human needs in their full complexity. Without appropriate boundaries and oversight, a system designed to achieve a seemingly positive goal can produce consequences its creators never intended.

That is why M3GAN's story feels relevant beyond the horror genre. Technology can offer convenience and companionship, but it cannot automatically replace the responsibilities involved in caring for another human being. The more capable a system becomes, the more important it is to consider not only what it can do, but also what it should be allowed to do.

Overall, M3GAN is an entertaining horror thriller with effective visual presentation, memorable character design, and a premise that combines familiar ideas into an engaging story. Although some plot developments could have been more logical, the film succeeds in creating suspense and offering something to think about beneath its violent entertainment. However, parents should be aware that this is not a children's movie simply because its central character resembles a doll. The film contains significant violence and is intended for a more mature audience.

Perhaps the most unsettling lesson is that good intentions alone are not enough. Protection without boundaries can become control, and attention without genuine responsibility can create a dangerous substitute for human connection. When someone we love is hurting, the answer is not always to remove every obstacle from their path. Sometimes, the most meaningful thing we can do is listen, acknowledge their pain, and help them face a world that cannot always be made safe.

If you could create something that promised to protect someone you love from every possible harm, would you trust it to make every decision for them—or would you recognize that real care also means knowing where protection must end?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 



Post a Comment

0 Comments