Murderer (2014) Review: Can a Killer’s Son Escape His Father’s Shadow?

 


Murderer (Original title: Sal in Ja) | 2014 | 1h 15m
Genre: Drama/Thriller | Country: South Korea
Director: Lee Gi-Wook | Writers: Lee Gi-Wook
Cast: Kim Hyun Su, Ahn Do-Gyoo, Ma Dong-seok
IMDB: 5.0
My Rate: 7/10

Joo-hyeop, a cold-blooded killer, lives with his son, Yong-ho, in a suburban area, concealing his true identity.  His secret is threatened when Ji Soo, a new student at his son's school, enters their lives and know his secret.

Warning:

Contains scenes of violence, sexual content, nudity, suicide, self-harm, and strong language.


Murderer (2014) Review: Is a Child Destined to Become Like His Father?

Can a good child be born to an evil parent? And if your father turns out to be a cold-blooded murderer, does that mean there is something evil flowing through your own veins?

These are the disturbing questions at the heart of Murderer (Sal in Ja), a South Korean drama thriller released in 2014. Directed and written by Lee Gi-Wook, the film stars Kim Hyun Su, Ahn Do-Gyoo, and Ma Dong-seok. With an IMDb rating of 5.0, I give it 7/10.

The story follows Joo-hyeop, a cold-blooded killer who lives on the outskirts of a city with his son, Yong-ho, while concealing his true identity. Their quiet life begins to unravel when Ji-soo, a new student at Yong-ho's school, enters their lives and discovers the secret his father has been hiding.

Yong-ho is a quiet, withdrawn boy who lives with his father, a dog breeder. At school, his classmates bully and exclude him because of his father's occupation, repeatedly telling him that he smells like a dog. The constant humiliation gradually pushes Yong-ho further into himself, leaving him isolated from the people around him.

One day, Yong-ho encounters Ji-soo hiding beneath a bridge. She has recently transferred from Seoul and is about to become his classmate. Although Ji-soo initially seems uninterested in getting to know him, their relationship begins to change after Yong-ho saves her from a group of bullies.

For a while, the two grow closer. But their fragile friendship is tested when Yong-ho accidentally injures one of the bullies with a knife while trying to protect Ji-soo. Instead of feeling grateful, Ji-soo becomes frightened and distances herself from him. Her fear deepens when she discovers the truth about Yong-ho's father.

Suddenly, Yong-ho finds himself facing a painful dilemma. He has not committed his father's crimes, yet the identity of the man who raised him threatens to destroy the one meaningful friendship he has managed to build. Can Yong-ho come to terms with who his father really is without beginning to question who he is destined to become?

According to the background information cited in the original review, Murderer was inspired by the real-life serial killer Kang Ho-soon, although the similarities between the real case and the film are not readily apparent. Rather than making the killer himself the central focus, Lee Gi-Wook takes a different approach by examining the situation from the perspective of the killer's son.

This is one of the film's most interesting choices. Stories about serial killers often concentrate on their crimes, their motives, or the people who become their victims. Murderer, however, shifts the focus toward someone who must live with the consequences of another person's actions without having chosen them. Through Yong-ho, the film explores the question of destiny: if a child is raised by a murderer, must he inevitably inherit his father's darkness?

The premise is compelling, particularly because it explores a perspective that is less frequently placed at the center of a thriller. Unfortunately, the execution leaves several aspects of the story underdeveloped, especially when it comes to narrative logic and character backgrounds.

The opening establishes the father's motive for one murder reasonably clearly. He kills a woman who turns out to be his unfaithful wife. However, if the film intends to establish him as a serial killer, it would have been helpful to reveal more about the motives behind his other murders. Understanding those crimes could have given viewers a clearer picture of the father's character and helped us better understand the emotional burden carried by his son.

The film wants us to experience the consequences of the father's identity through Yong-ho's eyes. Yet without enough information about the man himself, some of the emotional connections remain incomplete. We see the damage his existence causes, but we are not given enough insight into the person responsible for that damage.

Ji-soo's character also needs more development. As a girl who has recently moved from Seoul, she becomes a key figure in Yong-ho's life and an important catalyst for the story. The film briefly reveals that she encountered Yong-ho's father in the past and was placed in danger because of him. However, the circumstances surrounding her survival are not explored sufficiently.

How did Ji-soo manage to return to her family? How did her family react to what happened? What kind of trauma did she experience, and how did it shape her personality? These questions matter because her past should help us understand her reactions to Yong-ho and his father.

Instead, the relationship between Ji-soo and her mother appears strained, while the family's response to what seems to have been a life-threatening experience feels surprisingly understated. Considering what Ji-soo may have endured, the lack of a clearer emotional response from her family makes it harder to understand her character fully and connect with her experiences.

Another particularly questionable moment involves Yong-ho's teacher. The teacher initially appears kind, positive, and idealistic. Yet when Yong-ho asks whether a good child can be born to evil parents, the teacher essentially tells him that it is impossible because evil blood flows through the child's body.

This response is difficult to accept, especially from someone in a position of responsibility for educating and guiding children. A teacher's words can have a profound influence on how a young person understands himself. Instead of helping Yong-ho distinguish his own choices from his father's actions, the teacher reinforces the very fear that is tormenting him.

The idea that a child's moral character is predetermined by a parent's crimes is not only unconvincing; it also undermines the film's central dilemma. If Yong-ho is already condemned by his bloodline, what is left for him to question or decide?

The film does a reasonably good job of developing Yong-ho's internal conflict once he discovers his father's true identity. His relationship with Ji-soo becomes increasingly fragile, and the revelation strikes at the foundation of his understanding of himself. He must confront the possibility that the person he loves and depends on is someone capable of terrible violence.

However, the resolution feels less convincing than the conflict leading up to it. The story could have taken a different direction to better fulfill the purpose established by its original premise. Because Yong-ho's struggle revolves around identity, family, and the possibility of choosing one's own path, the ending needed to bring those questions together more effectively.

Despite these weaknesses, Murderer remains watchable. The cast delivers reasonably good performances, and the central idea gives the story an emotional dimension beyond the crimes themselves. Although the narrative could have been developed more thoroughly, its focus on the child of a murderer makes it an interesting thriller to explore.

The scene that stayed with me occurs after Yong-ho learns his father's true identity. He contacts Ji-soo, and his words reveal how shocked and disappointed he is by what he has discovered. Yet he does not simply hate his father. His father is the only person he has in his life.

That detail makes Yong-ho's situation especially painful. Discovering that someone has committed terrible acts does not automatically erase the emotional bond we have with that person. We can be disappointed in someone, feel disgusted by their actions, and still love them because they have been part of our lives for as long as we can remember.

For Yong-ho, his father is not merely a murderer whose crimes can be judged from a distance. He is also the person who has raised him and occupied the central place in his world. To reject his father completely might mean losing the only family he knows. But to accept him without question could mean ignoring the seriousness of his actions.

This is the emotional dilemma that makes Yong-ho's character worth considering. Loving someone does not necessarily mean approving of everything they do. At the same time, recognizing the truth about someone we love can force us to reconsider the memories, relationships, and sense of security we have built around them.

The film's memorable line, “If I drink good blood I could be a good person,” brings the question of inherited identity into even sharper focus. It suggests a desperate wish to believe that goodness can somehow be acquired, that a person can escape the darkness associated with their origins.

But goodness is not something we can guarantee through our bloodline, just as evil is not an inevitable inheritance. Our families influence us in countless ways, shaping our beliefs, habits, fears, and understanding of the world. Yet their choices do not automatically become ours.

We do not choose the family into which we are born. We cannot rewrite our parents' pasts, undo their mistakes, or erase the consequences of their actions. What we can do is decide how we respond to the circumstances we inherit. We can acknowledge the influence of our upbringing without allowing it to determine every choice we make.

That does not mean escaping a difficult family history is easy. Sometimes, the people who shape our earliest understanding of love are also the people who hurt us most deeply. Sometimes, accepting the truth about them means grieving the version of our family we wished we had. And sometimes, the hardest part is realizing that we can love someone without having to become like them.

Overall, Murderer is worth watching for viewers who enjoy dark dramas and thrillers that explore the psychological consequences of crime within a family. Its story has an intriguing premise, even if several character motivations and plot developments could have been handled more convincingly. The sad ending also reinforces the emotional weight of Yong-ho's dilemma, leaving the viewer with questions about family, identity, and the limits of personal choice.

What makes this story linger is not simply the idea of a child discovering that his father is a murderer. It is the fear that the world may judge him for something he never chose, and that he might eventually begin to believe those judgments himself. How much of who we are comes from the people who raised us, and how much comes from the choices we make? If you discovered something terrible about your family, would you see it as a part of your history—or as a sentence determining the person you must become?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 


Post a Comment

0 Comments