The Autopsy of Jane Doe (2016) Review: A Chilling Mystery That Could Have Gone Deeper

 


The Autopsy of Jane Doe | 2016 | 1h 26m
Genre: Body Horror/Witch Horror/Horror/Mystery/Thriller | Country: UK-US
Director: André Øvredal | Writers: Ian Goldberg, Richard Naing
Cast: Brian Cox, Emile Hirsch, Ophelia Lovibond
IMDB: 6.8
My Rate: 7/10

Tommy and Austin perform an autopsy on an unidentified woman's body found buried at the site of a family massacre, leading to strange and dangerous events that threaten their lives.

Warning:

Contains disturbing images, nudity, and violence.


Sometimes, the most terrifying things are not the ones that chase us in the dark, but the ones we cannot explain. What would you do if a seemingly lifeless body began turning an ordinary night at work into a nightmare, while every attempt to understand it only made things worse? The Autopsy of Jane Doe builds its horror around this unsettling question, bringing mystery and supernatural terror into a place where everything is supposed to have a rational explanation.

The story begins with a brutal murder in a house where every occupant has been killed. There are no obvious signs of forced entry, leaving the circumstances of the massacre difficult to understand. The mystery deepens when the police discover the body of an unidentified woman buried in the basement. Despite the violence surrounding the scene, her body appears remarkably free of external injuries.

Tommy operates a family-run mortuary and crematorium, a business passed down through generations. His son, Austin, helps him run it, although he has little desire to continue the family tradition. He plans to leave with his girlfriend, Emma, and build a different life for himself.

After finishing an autopsy on another body, Austin prepares to go out with Emma. His plans change when a police officer arrives with a serious expression and asks Tommy to examine the unidentified woman found at the murder scene. Tommy agrees to take the case, and Austin decides to stay and help his father.

The woman, whom they call Jane Doe, presents an extraordinary medical mystery. Her skin appears smooth and unmarked, yet the bones in her wrists and ankles are broken. As Tommy and Austin continue the examination, they discover more abnormalities that make her condition increasingly difficult to explain.

Then the strange events begin. Footsteps echo through the building, doors open on their own, and the radio suddenly changes its music. Austin senses that something is terribly wrong with the body, but Tommy insists on continuing the autopsy. Their determination to uncover the truth gradually puts both men in danger.

The premise of The Autopsy of Jane Doe is genuinely intriguing. An unidentified body, a seemingly impossible set of injuries, and a murder scene filled with unanswered questions provide a strong foundation for a horror mystery. Unfortunately, I feel that the execution does not fully live up to the potential of its own idea. There are moments when the story could have been developed more deeply to make its mystery and horror more memorable.

The opening sequence is effective, particularly its use of blurred imagery to create uncertainty. Combined with the music and sound design, it establishes an atmosphere of mystery before the film reveals too much. The setting also works well: a mortuary at night is already unsettling, and the increasingly strange events make the confined environment feel even more threatening.

The tension and supernatural terror are handled reasonably well. The film includes several jump scares, although some are predictable enough that their impact is reduced. More importantly, while the atmosphere creates suspense, I did not find the overall experience as frightening or lingering as I had hoped. Some parts of the story and its disturbing events feel as though they could have been explored in greater depth.

The performances are decent, but none feels particularly exceptional to me. At times, the expressions and dialogue seem emotionally restrained, leaving certain moments feeling a little empty. Some small details also weaken the film's otherwise carefully constructed tension.

For example, there is a scene in which Tommy asks Austin to stab him in the chest with a knife. Earlier, the knife is positioned far from Tommy, while Austin is standing nearby. Yet Austin suddenly has the knife ready in his hand, without the film showing when he picked it up. It is a small continuity issue, but details like this can pull viewers out of an otherwise tense scene.

Spoilers ahead. Another questionable moment occurs when the police carry the bodies out of the mortuary. Only two body bags are taken away, even though there should be three bodies. What happened to Emma? Why is her body not among those being removed? The omission is distracting, especially because the film gives no clear explanation for it.

The police officer's apparent lack of awareness is also difficult to accept. Tommy contacted him that night, and given the strange circumstances and the uncertainty surrounding what was happening inside the mortuary, I would have expected him to recognize that something was seriously wrong. Instead, his response feels insufficiently attentive to the situation.

I also think the film's conspiracy involving witches could have been presented more effectively. Much of the explanation is delivered through Tommy's dialogue, rather than being brought to life visually. Showing fragments of Jane Doe's past, including the horrifying events that may have happened to her, could have made the revelation more powerful. Such scenes might also have given the character a stronger presence beyond being a body lying on an examination table. Even without extensive dialogue, visual storytelling could have helped audiences connect with her suffering and understand the horror behind her condition.

One of the most memorable scenes, however, has little to do with the supernatural mystery itself. Tommy and Austin discover their cat, which is still alive but gravely injured inside an air vent. Unable to bear watching the animal suffer, Tommy breaks its neck to end its pain quickly before cremating it.

It is a painful scene, but it reveals something important about Tommy. He cannot stand to see something he loves trapped in unbearable suffering, and he chooses what he believes is the most merciful way to end it. At the same time, the scene captures the difficult reality of loss: sometimes, caring about someone means confronting the pain of letting go rather than prolonging suffering simply because we are not ready to say goodbye.

That moment gives the film an emotional dimension that I wish had been developed more consistently. Horror can be more than frightening images and unexplained events. It can also explore helplessness, grief, guilt, and the limits of what we can do to protect the people or beings we love.

The line that stays with me is, “All these mistakes, my mistakes.” It reflects the weight of regret and the tendency to look back at painful events through the lens of everything we believe we should have done differently. Yet not every tragedy can be prevented, and not every outcome is within our control. Sometimes, the hardest part is accepting what has happened without allowing regret to define everything that comes afterward.

Overall, The Autopsy of Jane Doe is an interesting horror film with a strong central mystery, an effective atmosphere, and enough disturbing moments to keep viewers engaged. However, I feel that its execution leaves several opportunities unexplored. The story could have benefited from deeper development, more convincing details, and a more visual exploration of the witch-related conspiracy. Its cliffhanger ending leaves questions lingering, although not every unanswered question feels equally satisfying.

One important consideration is its disturbing imagery. The film shows internal organs in detailed, close-up shots, so viewers who are uncomfortable with graphic bodily imagery may find it difficult to watch. For those who enjoy body horror mixed with mystery and supernatural elements, however, it remains worth watching.

Perhaps the most unsettling question the film leaves us with is not simply what happened to Jane Doe, but how we respond when we face suffering that we cannot understand or undo. When regret, fear, and helplessness leave us searching for someone or something to blame, can we accept the limits of our control—and find a way to make peace with what we cannot change?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments