Bird
Box: Barcelona | 2023 | 1h 52m
Genre:
Monster Horror/Psychological Horror/Psychological Thriller/Suspense
Mystery/Horror/Mystery/Sci-Fi/Thriller | Country: US-Spain
Director:
David Pastor, Àlex Pastor | Writers: Àlex Pastor, David Pastor
Cast:
Mario Casas, Georgina Campbell, Diego Calva
IMDB:
5.3
My
Rate: 7/10
Sebastian and Anna embark on a journey they believe can free trapped souls by finding people still hiding from a mysterious entity that causes those who see it to end their lives. Sebastian tries every way to make people see the entity, until an encounter with Sophia causes his faith to collapse.
Warning:
Contains violent scenes, harsh language, suicide, and sensual content.
What if the person you believe you are saving is actually
the person you are hurting? Bird Box: Barcelona (2023) explores this
disturbing question through Sebastian, a father navigating a world where seeing
a mysterious entity drives most people to take their own lives. Unlike the
first Bird Box (2018), which follows survivors trying to avoid the
creature, this spin-off introduces us to the perspective of the people known as
“seers”—those who can look at the entity and remain alive, but become convinced
that others must see it too.
Sebastian and his daughter, Anna, travel through the
devastated streets of Barcelona, searching for survivors. They believe their
mission will free the souls trapped in a world they no longer understand.
Sebastian tries to persuade people to look at the entity, convinced that he is
helping them. However, his encounter with a young girl named Sophia gradually
challenges everything he believes.
The story begins with Sebastian and Anna trying to survive
amid the chaos caused by the mysterious entity. They encounter a group of
survivors taking shelter in a bus. Among them is a man who has lost his eyes.
He explains that he encountered the seers, who tried to force him to look at
the entity. Rather than submit, he chose to gouge out his own eyes. Sebastian
later meets a doctor who helps stitch a wound near his temple.
While the survivors sleep, Sebastian sneaks into a storage
room to find the bus keys. The doctor wakes up and attempts to stop him, but
Sebastian gets the keys first. He starts the bus and drives it away from the
shelter, exposing the group to the entity. The survivors see it and take their
own lives.
The truth is that Sebastian is himself a seer. He believes
he is freeing lost souls, and he interprets the light he sees leaving the
bodies of his victims as evidence that he is doing something good. With Anna
beside him, he continues searching for more people to “save,” unaware—or
unwilling to accept—that his actions are destroying other people's lives.
Sebastian eventually encounters another group of survivors
led by Rafa. They live in a bunker alongside Octavio, the married couple
Roberto and Isabel, Claire, and Sophia. Sebastian gains their trust by claiming
that he knows where to find a generator.
However, carrying out his plan becomes more difficult
because he needs to manipulate the entire group rather than a few individuals.
His opportunity comes when Sophia mentions a safe place she heard about on the
radio: Montjuïc Castle. She became separated from her mother while trying to
reach it, and Sebastian uses this information to persuade the group to leave
the bunker.
He manipulates Rafa and Octavio's dog leashes, causing chaos
when the entity appears and ultimately leading to Rafa's death. Yet Sebastian's
interactions with Sophia begin to weaken his convictions. He starts questioning
Anna's presence, particularly when he realizes that he no longer sees the light
he once associated with the souls of the people he kills after Octavio's death.
As they continue toward their destination, another group of seers emerges,
creating an additional threat.
The central question becomes whether Sebastian can abandon
his delusions and help the people he has been manipulating reach safety.
Directed by David Pastor and Àlex Pastor, Bird Box:
Barcelona is a spin-off sequel to Bird Box (2018). The fundamental
premise remains the same: a mysterious entity drives people who see it to take
their own lives. However, the perspective is substantially different. Rather
than focusing primarily on the blindfolded survivors, this film examines the
seers, people who survive seeing the entity but become convinced that they must
make others see it as well.
I find this change of perspective interesting because it
expands the original concept beyond the struggle to survive an invisible
threat. The danger now comes not only from the entity but also from people
whose beliefs have been distorted by their encounter with it. They do not
necessarily perceive themselves as villains. Some genuinely believe that they
are helping others, which makes their actions even more disturbing.
The film uses a mostly chronological narrative, with
occasional flashbacks that provide additional context. Unlike the first film,
which relies more heavily on transitions between past and present, the
flashbacks here are relatively brief. The transitions are generally clear, and
the story remains easy to follow.
The backgrounds of the main characters are established
reasonably well, particularly Sebastian's. Although not every character
receives the same level of development, the film provides enough context to
understand the protagonist's motivations and the emotional conflict that
gradually unfolds within him.
The suspense is also handled fairly well. The danger does
not come exclusively from the entity; encounters with other seers create
additional threats, while Sebastian's internal struggle becomes increasingly
important to the narrative. His growing uncertainty provides an emotional
dimension that distinguishes the film from a straightforward survival horror
story.
However, I have mixed feelings about the ending. The
resolution could have been effective if the story had concluded after the
characters reached the safe shelter, echoing the hopeful conclusion of the
first film. Instead, the additional sequence involving the military's attempts
to develop a countermeasure by collecting DNA samples from seers makes the
story less convincing to me. The scene raises questions about how the military
understands the entity and what its research is actually expected to accomplish.
Rather than adding a satisfying new dimension, this development feels somewhat
implausible and unnecessary.
The performances are generally adequate, although some feel
stiff or less convincing than they could have been. The chemistry between
characters is not always strong, and certain exchanges sound awkward. These
weaknesses occasionally make it difficult to become fully immersed in the
relationships that are supposed to drive the emotional story.
On the technical side, the camera work and cinematography
are effective. Some scenes give viewers the impression of seeing the world from
the creature's perspective, while the visual effects make its appearances feel
more tangible. The film also offers more frequent interactions with the entity
than the first Bird Box, which may appeal to viewers who want to see
more of the supernatural threat.
Nevertheless, I still prefer the first film. In Bird Box
(2018), the deaths caused by the entity often carry a stronger emotional impact
because of the characters' circumstances and the relationships established
before those moments occur. In Bird Box: Barcelona, some deaths feel
more random and less meaningful, reducing their emotional weight despite the
increased interaction with the creature.
One of the most memorable scenes occurs when Sebastian tries
to remove Sophia's blindfold. He hesitates because he is caught between his
growing connection with the girl and the influence of the figure he believes to
be Anna. As he begins to recognize that Anna's presence may be a manipulation
created by the entity, his certainty starts to crumble.
This scene reveals the deeper emotional wound behind
Sebastian's behavior. He has not truly let go of his daughter, and his
unresolved grief has kept him attached to an imagined version of her. That
attachment has shaped his understanding of the world and allowed him to justify
actions that hurt other people.
The line that captures this conflict is: "What if
I'm not the shepherd, Anna?"
It is a simple question, but it signals a profound shift in
Sebastian's thinking. For the first time, he begins to consider the possibility
that he is not the person guiding lost souls to freedom but someone leading
innocent people toward their destruction.
This is where the film becomes more than a supernatural
thriller. It offers a reflection on how trauma can distort our thinking and
influence the choices we make. When we cannot accept a painful loss, we may
cling to beliefs that help us avoid confronting reality. Sometimes, those
beliefs become so deeply rooted that we mistake our own suffering for a mission
or a purpose.
Sebastian's experience also reminds us that good intentions
do not automatically make our actions good. A person may sincerely believe they
are helping others while causing serious harm because they refuse to question
their assumptions. Recognizing that possibility requires more than courage; it
requires the willingness to admit that the story we have told ourselves might
be wrong.
Overall, I rate Bird Box: Barcelona 7/10. It remains
an enjoyable supernatural horror film with an interesting shift in perspective,
some tense sequences, and a protagonist whose emotional struggle gives the
story added depth. Although the performances, character chemistry, and final
developments could have been stronger, the film can be watched independently
because it tells a different story from the original. However, for a fuller
understanding of the concept and its world, I recommend watching Bird Box
(2018) first.
The cliffhanger ending leaves room for further questions,
but the most important question may not be about the entity at all. When grief
makes us desperate to believe that we are doing the right thing, how willing
are we to question ourselves before our pain begins hurting the people who need
us most?
(Aluna Uwie)
Previously published on Alunauwie.com
This article was originally written in Indonesian and has
been adapted into English for international readers.

0 Comments