Dear
Ex (Original title: Shei xian ai shang ta de) | 2018 | 1h 40m
Genre:
Comedy/Drama/Romance | Country: Taiwan
Director:
Chih-Yen Hsu, Mag Hsu | Writers: Mag Hsu, Shih-yuan Lu
Cast:
Roy Chiu, Ying-Hsuan Hsieh, Spark Chen
IMDB:
7.3
My
Rate: 10/10
Song Cheng-xi must be caught between his stubborn mother and his father’s lover due to the issue of his father’s death insurance money being given to the lover. The problem worsens after Cheng-xi chooses to leave his mother and live with the lover.
Warning:
Contains
scenes of harsh language, violence, and LGBT themes.
“He
had decided to just be himself in the remaining days of his life.”
What
happens when the person you love leaves you for someone else—and even after
their death, you are still expected to accept the choices they made? Dear Ex
(2018), a Taiwanese comedy-drama directed by Chih-Yen Hsu and Mag Hsu, explores
the complicated emotions that emerge when grief, betrayal, and love collide.
Beneath its humorous moments lies a deeply moving story about a family
struggling to understand one another after the death of the man who connected
them.
Liu
San-Lian (Hsieh Ying-Hsuan) takes her son, Song Cheng-xi (Joseph Huang), to
confront Jay (Roy Chiu), the man who was her late husband Song Zhen-yuan's
lover. The life insurance money Zhen-yuan left behind has been transferred to
Jay, leaving San-Lian furious and determined to reclaim it. She believes the
money belongs to her family, and she is unwilling to accept that her husband's
lover has become its beneficiary. However, their confrontation at Jay's
apartment does not go as she hopes.
San-Lian
and Cheng-xi already have a difficult relationship, and their arguments grow
more intense when she throws away the belongings Zhen-yuan left behind. Unable
to tolerate his mother's behavior, Cheng-xi leaves home and goes to stay with
Jay. Jay reluctantly allows the boy to remain in his apartment temporarily,
creating an unusual living arrangement between two people who have every reason
to distrust each other.
At
first, Cheng-xi sees Jay as a bad person. He cannot understand why his father
chose to leave his family and enter a relationship with another man. Living
together gives him the opportunity to observe Jay more closely, however, and
gradually, his initial judgment begins to change. The more time they spend
together, the more he realizes that the situation may be more complicated than
he first believed.
Jay,
meanwhile, is struggling with his own grief. Although he may appear to be doing
fine, he is still trying to come to terms with Zhen-yuan's death. He also faces
the challenge of keeping his theater running. The theater and the story the
troupe plans to perform are deeply connected to Zhen-yuan, making it difficult
for Jay to separate his work from the memories of the man he loved. Just as he
is trying to find a way forward, San-Lian and Cheng-xi enter his life and bring
new complications.
For
San-Lian, the pain is equally profound, though it takes a different form. She
feels betrayed by her husband's decision to have another relationship, and
discovering that he changed the beneficiary of his life insurance to Jay makes
her feel even more rejected. The situation becomes more painful when her own
son chooses to live with the man she considers responsible for the destruction
of her family.
Despite
her anger, San-Lian continues trying to be a good mother. She still cares about
Cheng-xi, sometimes showing her concern indirectly rather than openly
expressing it. Yet her own wounds remain unresolved, and the pain of feeling
abandoned cannot simply disappear because she wants to do the right thing.
As
the three characters spend more time dealing with one another, their
relationships become increasingly complicated. Feelings remain unspoken,
misunderstandings persist, and the boundaries between resentment, affection,
and grief become difficult to define. Can they find a way to understand one
another when each of them is mourning the same man but experiencing his absence
in a completely different way?
One
of the most compelling aspects of Dear Ex is its premise. Inspired by a
story involving a friend of Hsu whose husband had a relationship with another
man, the film explores a subject that remains sensitive in many societies,
particularly in parts of Asia where same-sex relationships can still be treated
as taboo.
However,
the film does not focus primarily on the romantic or sexual aspects of the
relationship between the two men. Instead, it places the characters' emotions
at the center of the story. Their grief, anger, jealousy, affection, and
confusion are given room to develop, allowing each character to become more
than a simple representative of a particular identity or social issue.
This
is what makes the film so effective. It is not merely a story about a husband
who had a male lover, a wife who feels betrayed, or a child caught between two
adults. It is about people trying to cope with a loss while struggling to
reconcile their own version of the past with the realities they must face in
the present.
The
narrative is presented systematically, although it does not follow a completely
linear timeline. At certain points, the audience is taken back to the past to
understand the relationships between the characters. Rather than making the
story confusing, these transitions deepen our understanding of their
circumstances and motivations.
The
storytelling is particularly effective because it introduces the three central
characters together before gradually revealing their individual perspectives.
Each character receives meaningful attention, and their separate experiences
eventually come together to form a cohesive emotional narrative. We begin to
understand why they behave as they do, even when their decisions are difficult
to accept.
The
conflict is also developed with considerable care. At first, the insurance
money appears to be the main source of the dispute. Yet as the story unfolds,
it becomes clear that the money is merely a trigger for deeper wounds. Beneath
the arguments lies a more painful question: what does it mean to feel betrayed
by someone you loved, especially when that person is no longer alive to explain
their choices?
The
confrontations between the characters are intense because their emotions are
not limited to anger over money. They are also fighting to have their pain
acknowledged. Each character has something to lose, something they cannot fully
express, and a different understanding of what Zhen-yuan's choices mean. These
conflicting emotions create tension that feels personal rather than
artificially manufactured.
The
resolution is equally satisfying. As the characters gradually develop and begin
to understand their circumstances, their problems start to find answers. The
ending offers a sense of relief and emotional warmth without making their
earlier suffering feel meaningless. It is moving because the characters do not
simply overcome their problems; they learn to see one another differently.
The
acting is another major strength. Both the leading and supporting actors
deliver convincing performances that feel natural rather than stiff or
exaggerated. The chemistry between the cast members makes their relationships
believable, particularly during the more emotionally charged confrontations.
Roy Chiu and Hsieh Ying-Hsuan are especially compelling, and their performances
received significant recognition, including acting awards for their work in the
film.
The
music and sound effects are also carefully selected to complement each scene.
The original soundtrack, “Bali Song,” received recognition as Best Original
Film Song. Beyond being pleasant to listen to, the song adds emotional weight
to the story and helps certain moments linger in the audience's memory.
Technically,
the cinematography and camera movements are handled well, capturing the details
of the characters and their surroundings. The predominantly brown color palette
creates a calm, contemplative atmosphere that suits the film's emotional depth.
The dialogue is also meaningful, with conversations contributing to our
understanding of the characters rather than feeling like unnecessary
exposition.
The
scene that moved me most is when San-Lian, overwhelmed by despair, cries before
a deity's altar. She questions what sins she has committed to deserve such
suffering when she believes she has worked hard to be a good wife and mother.
Her disappointment is so profound that she begins to consider becoming a bad
person herself.
This
scene is painful because it reflects a question many people ask when life
treats them unfairly: What did I do to deserve this?
Sometimes,
we try our best to be good partners, parents, friends, or human beings,
believing that our efforts will protect us from certain kinds of pain. When
something terrible happens anyway, we may begin to question not only the people
who hurt us but also our own worth and the meaning of our goodness.
San-Lian's
anger is understandable, even when her behavior hurts the people around her.
She has lost her husband, discovered a truth that challenges her understanding
of their marriage, and found herself fighting over something she believes
should have belonged to her family. Her grief is tangled with humiliation,
resentment, and the feeling that her efforts have meant nothing.
It
is easy to judge someone who responds to pain with anger or bitterness. But
this scene reminds us that people do not always become difficult because they
have always been cruel. Sometimes, they are struggling with wounds they do not
know how to process. Some continue trying to be good despite their suffering,
while others allow their disappointment to change the way they treat the world.
There
is a familiar saying that bad people are often made from good people who have
been hurt. While pain does not excuse every harmful action, it can help us
understand how resentment grows. Being hurt does not automatically make someone
cruel, just as being a good person does not guarantee that they will never
suffer.
What
matters is what we choose to do with that pain. We may not be able to control
what others do to us, but we can still reflect on whether our suffering is
turning us into someone we never wanted to become.
The
dialogue, “He had decided to just be himself in the remaining days of his
life,” also captures one of the film's most important ideas. It suggests the
significance of living honestly, even when doing so challenges the expectations
of others. Yet the film also acknowledges that personal freedom can have
complicated consequences for the people we leave behind. Being true to
ourselves does not erase the emotions of those affected by our choices, but
neither does their pain necessarily mean that our lives should be dictated
entirely by their expectations.
Overall,
Dear Ex is a must-watch for anyone who appreciates emotionally rich
dramas about family, grief, complicated relationships, and the difficult
process of letting go. Its thoughtful narrative, excellent performances,
meaningful soundtrack, and balanced mixture of humor and sadness make it a
deeply satisfying experience.
The
film reminds us that grief rarely belongs to just one person, and that the same
loss can mean something entirely different to everyone involved. Sometimes,
understanding begins when we stop treating our own pain as the only truth and
become willing to see the hurt carried by others.
When
life disappoints us despite our best efforts, will we allow that pain to turn
us against the world, or can we find a way to acknowledge our wounds without
losing the parts of ourselves we still want to protect?
(Aluna
Uwie)
Previously
published on Alunauwie.com
This
article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English
for international readers.

0 Comments