Flatliners (2017) Review: The Deadly Side Effect Behind a Medical Experiment

 

Flatliners (2017) Movie Review

Flatliners | 2017 | 1h 49m
Genre: Psychological Horror/Teen Horror/Drama/Horror/Mystery/Sci-Fi/Thriller | Country: US
Director: Niels Arden Oplev | Writers: Peter Filardi, Ben Ripley
Cast: Elliot Page, Diego Luna, Nina Dobrev
IMDB: 5.2
My Rate: 7/10

Courtney tries to conduct an experiment related to death in order to meet her deceased sister. The heightened brain activity becomes a side effect that makes her friends want to do the same, unaware of the harmful effects awaiting them.

Warning:

Contains scenes of violence, strong language, nudity, sensuality, sex, alcohol, and drugs.

 

What if you could briefly stop your heart, experience what lies beyond life, and return with a sharper mind than before? Would you be tempted to try it, even if you knew there might be consequences you could never take back? Flatliners (2017) explores this dangerous temptation through a group of medical students who experiment with death, hoping to discover what lies beyond it. But when their experiences begin to follow them back into the real world, their pursuit of knowledge turns into a struggle against guilt, fear, and the consequences of their own ambition.

Courtney is a medical student obsessed with the possibility of life after death. Haunted by the loss of her younger sister, she wants to conduct a flatline experiment by deliberately stopping her heart for a short period. Hoping to discover what happens after death, she asks Sophia and Jamie for help.

Courtney prepares everything in a basement room at the hospital, including a brain scanner to record her brain activity while she is clinically dead. She quickly explains what Sophia and Jamie need to do to stop her heart and bring her back. Neither of them initially realizes that they are being drawn into the experiment until Courtney begins the procedure without giving them much opportunity to object.

The experiment quickly goes wrong. Sophia and Jamie struggle to revive Courtney and, frightened by the situation, Sophia sends a message to Ray for help. Ray rushes to the room, followed by Marlo, and together they manage to save Courtney just in time.

Afterward, Courtney describes her experience, astonishing her friends. Even more impressive is the apparent improvement in her cognitive abilities: she can recall information she has previously studied with remarkable speed. Her experience sparks the curiosity of the others, especially Jamie, who wants to undergo the same procedure.

During his own experience, Jamie encounters memories of his former girlfriend. What initially seems like a beautiful reunion takes a disturbing turn when the sound of a baby interrupts the experience and brings him back to consciousness.

Soon, Courtney and Jamie begin experiencing strange disturbances. Their encounters become increasingly unsettling, but neither tells the others what is happening. Eventually, Marlo and Sophia also decide to undergo flatlining, although their experiences are not as positive as Courtney's and Jamie's.

As the consequences spread through the group, the students must confront the question they failed to consider before beginning their experiments: can they find a way to escape the disturbing effects of repeatedly crossing the boundary between life and death?

Despite sharing its title and central premise with Flatliners (1990), this film is not simply a remake in terms of its characters and storyline. It presents a different group of medical students and a new narrative built around the same fundamental idea. It can therefore be viewed as a standalone story, even though its connection to the earlier film could have been explored more meaningfully.

One particularly missed opportunity is the appearance of Kiefer Sutherland, who played Nelson in the 1990 film. His presence could have provided a stronger link between the two stories, but the connection is not developed in a way that significantly enriches the narrative.

The film's relatively low IMDb rating may partly reflect the expectations surrounding its title. Many viewers appear to approach it as a remake of the original rather than as a separate story connected by a shared concept. This naturally encourages comparisons between the two films, which can make it difficult to evaluate the 2017 version on its own merits.

Viewed independently, however, Flatliners (2017) is not necessarily a bad film. Its premise is interesting, and the idea of medical students discovering unexpected benefits from a near-death experience offers plenty of possibilities. The problem lies mainly in the execution. The story has potential, but it does not explore that potential as thoroughly as it could.

The character backgrounds and introductions feel underdeveloped. The film opens with Courtney experiencing an accident, an event that should provide an important foundation for understanding her motivations. However, the scene quickly transitions to the hospital and the other characters, leaving the opening feeling more like an isolated incident than a meaningful starting point for the story.

This rushed introduction weakens the narrative foundation. Courtney's decision to conduct the experiment follows so quickly that her actions can feel abrupt, particularly when she effectively corners Sophia and Jamie into helping her. Their involvement would have been more convincing if the film had spent more time developing their relationships and showing why they would agree to participate in such a dangerous experiment.

The other students' motivations are somewhat easier to understand. Seeing Courtney's cognitive abilities improve gives them a tangible reason to consider the procedure themselves. Their ambitions to excel academically also make the experiment appealing, even though they underestimate its potential consequences.

The film attempts to explore several types of conflict, including personal struggles, family relationships, friendships, and romantic relationships. This variety gives the story opportunities to examine how each character responds to guilt and unresolved emotions. Unfortunately, the conflicts do not always receive enough development to make their emotional consequences feel fully earned.

The resolution is also rushed. As a result, some of the film's messages lack the depth they could have had. The shift in focus from Courtney, who initially drives the story, to Marlo also makes the later portions feel somewhat disjointed. Instead of developing naturally from the central character's journey, the resolution can feel as though the film is forcing its pieces together to reach the ending.

Nevertheless, the performances offer some compensation. Elliot Page delivers a particularly strong performance as Courtney, conveying the character's grief, determination, and growing fear. Some of the other performances feel awkward or frustrating at times, but the cast generally does a reasonable job of bringing the characters' struggles to life. The cinematography and music also contribute positively to the atmosphere.

There are, however, several choices in the dialogue and scenes that could have been improved. Some of Sophia's lines feel unnecessary, adding little to the story or the development of her character. The party scenes are another example. Watching the students drink and celebrate shortly after returning from clinical death feels difficult to accept. Even within the film's fictional premise, such an extreme procedure should leave them concerned about their physical and mental well-being. The original Flatliners (1990) handles this aspect more convincingly by showing characters who need substantial rest after their experiments.

The emergency procedures also invite comparison. In the 1990 film, the students immediately use a defibrillator when attempting to revive their friend, reflecting the urgency of the situation. In the 2017 version, the characters rely heavily on CPR, which does not always appear convincing, while the defibrillator seems to become an option only much later, despite being available. These moments can undermine the credibility of a story that depends on viewers believing its characters are medical students.

Even so, the film's central idea remains compelling. The students are not simply seeking an extraordinary experience; they are also driven by ambition, grief, and the desire to understand things that ordinary life cannot explain. Their experiment exposes the danger of pursuing an answer without considering whether they are prepared for what they might discover.

The scene that leaves the strongest impression occurs when Courtney realizes that the disturbances she is experiencing are becoming increasingly severe. She records a confession for her friends, acknowledging that her obsession with seeing her deceased sister again has brought them all into a terrifying situation. She feels responsible for exposing them to something they never anticipated.

This moment reveals an important side of Courtney's character. Although her actions put her friends in danger, she never intended to hurt them. Her experiment began with personal grief and a desperate desire for one more encounter with someone she had lost. When she finally recognizes the consequences, her guilt becomes overwhelming.

The memorable line, "You have to forgive yourself," captures the emotional heart of the film. Sometimes, the most difficult person to forgive is ourselves. We may understand intellectually that we cannot change the past, yet still punish ourselves for decisions we regret or things we wish we had done differently. Learning to forgive ourselves does not mean pretending that our mistakes never happened. It means accepting responsibility while allowing ourselves the chance to grow beyond them.

Overall, Flatliners (2017) is a watchable psychological horror film with an intriguing premise, decent performances, and an atmosphere that supports its darker themes. Its underdeveloped characters, rushed conflicts, and questionable medical decisions prevent it from reaching its full potential, especially when compared with the 1990 film. Still, I rate it 7/10 and consider it worth watching, provided viewers approach it as a separate interpretation of the concept rather than expecting it to match the original. Please note that it contains violence, strong language, nudity, sensual and sexual content, alcohol, and drug use.

Perhaps the most important lesson is that not every boundary exists simply to be crossed. Curiosity can lead to discovery, but ambition without caution can put both ourselves and the people around us at risk. And when our choices cause harm, we must find the courage to acknowledge what we have done and learn to forgive ourselves. If your desire to recover something you had lost began to hurt the people still beside you, would you recognize when it was time to stop?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments