The Theory of Everything (2014) Review: The Love Story Behind Stephen Hawking’s Greatest Struggles

 

The Theory of Everything (2014)

The Theory of Everything | 2014 | 2h 3m
Genre: DocuDrama/Medical Drama/Biography/Drama/Romance | Country: UK
Director: James Marsh | Writers: Anthony McCarten, Jane Hawking
Cast: Eddie Redmayne, Felicity Jones, Tom Prior
IMDB: 7.7
My Rate: 10/10

Stephen Hawking’s life changed when he was diagnosed with Motor Neuron Disease at the age of 21, and Jane’s presence beside him gave him the spirit to keep pursuing all his dreams, but the journey was not easy for both, especially with his worsening illness.

Warning:

Contains sensual scenes and strong language.


Some people change the way we understand the universe, while others quietly help them find the strength to keep exploring it. The Theory of Everything (2014) tells the story of Stephen Hawking, a brilliant physicist whose life took an unexpected turn when he was diagnosed with motor neuron disease at just 21. Alongside his remarkable scientific achievements, the film explores his relationship with Jane Hawking, whose presence gave him the encouragement to keep pursuing his dreams. Yet their journey was far from easy, especially as Stephen’s condition continued to deteriorate.

The story begins when Stephen Hawking is pursuing postgraduate studies in astrophysics at the University of Cambridge. At a party, he meets Jane Wilde, a literature student, and the two gradually develop a close relationship. Although Jane’s friend initially considers Stephen a little unusual, his intelligence is undeniable. His professors have high expectations of him, and his ideas offer fresh insights into discussions about physics. Despite his intellectual ability, however, Stephen struggles to find a subject for his thesis until a seminar about black holes inspires him.

Just as Stephen becomes increasingly enthusiastic about his research, his body begins to fail him. It starts with difficulty moving his hands and eventually culminates in a fall while he is walking across campus. After being taken to the hospital, he receives a devastating diagnosis: motor neuron disease, also known as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). The illness will affect his physical abilities but not necessarily his intellectual capacity. Nevertheless, his doctors estimate that he has only two years left to live.

The diagnosis plunges Stephen into depression. He withdraws from his friends and Jane, struggling to face a future that suddenly seems unbearably short. Jane, however, refuses to let him give up. With her encouragement, Stephen finds the strength to continue his work, completes his thesis, and eventually marries her.

Marriage brings them happiness, but it also introduces challenges neither could have fully anticipated. As Stephen’s physical condition worsens and he becomes increasingly dependent on a wheelchair, he remains committed to his research. Jane, meanwhile, takes on the exhausting responsibility of caring for Stephen and their children. In the process, her own education and personal aspirations are pushed aside.

Eventually, Jane follows her aunt’s advice to join a church choir, hoping to find some relief from her overwhelming responsibilities and reclaim a little time for herself. There, she meets Jonathan, who later helps her care for Stephen. His presence becomes significant in the lives of the entire family. However, as their third child is born, doubts emerge within the family about the child’s paternity. These suspicions create tension between Jane and Stephen’s family, and Jonathan eventually chooses to step away to prevent the conflict from escalating.

Can Stephen and Jane overcome the growing difficulties in their relationship, or will the weight of their circumstances eventually pull them apart?

The Theory of Everything is adapted from Jane Hawking’s 2007 memoir, Travelling to Infinity: My Life with Stephen. The film follows approximately three decades of Stephen’s life, from the beginning of his relationship with Jane and his initial diagnosis to his achievements in the scientific world. It takes us through happiness, despair, sacrifice, and, ultimately, a deeply moving resolution.

Stephen Hawking is a renowned physicist whose work transformed our understanding of the universe. His ideas about time have also shaped my own interest in the possibility of time travel. In his discussions of the universe and time, the idea that changing or revisiting the past could lead to different branches of events is particularly fascinating to me. What I admire most about Stephen, however, is his determination to keep thinking, questioning, and testing his ideas despite the physical limitations imposed by his illness. His body may have become increasingly restricted, but his intellectual curiosity never stopped.

Returning to the film itself, I think it tells its story exceptionally well. The narrative is carefully structured, making it easy to follow while gradually drawing the audience into Stephen and Jane’s lives. The film does not require viewers to know much about Stephen Hawking beforehand because it establishes the characters and their circumstances in sufficient detail. We witness how Stephen and Jane meet, build their relationship, confront his diagnosis, and begin a marriage that initially seems full of hope.

The conflict develops gradually as Stephen’s health deteriorates. We see Jane struggling to manage nearly everything on her own, often neglecting her own needs in the process. Her emotional exhaustion becomes increasingly apparent, and the arrival of Jonathan introduces another dimension to her life. The doubts surrounding their family situation add further tension, while Elaine’s eventual presence becomes a turning point in the relationship between Stephen and Jane.

What makes this progression effective is that the film does not present their difficulties as a single dramatic event. Instead, the strain accumulates through years of caregiving, changing needs, and personal sacrifices. Love can provide strength, but it does not automatically eliminate exhaustion or guarantee that two people will continue to want the same things from life.

The resolution is particularly moving. The characters undergo meaningful changes, and we see their lives gradually take new directions. Stephen appears to become somewhat more open to the possibility of God's existence, while the people around him begin to find their own paths forward. One of the film’s most touching moments comes when memories of the lives Stephen and Jane shared are presented through flashbacks. The sequence invites us to revisit their beginning and remember how much they have experienced together. It also echoes the film’s interest in time and the possibility of reversing it to discover where things began, creating a meaningful connection to the title itself.

Another major strength is the casting. Eddie Redmayne delivers a remarkable performance as Stephen Hawking, capturing not only his physical deterioration but also the distinctive mannerisms and expressions associated with him. The resemblance to the real Stephen is striking, and Redmayne’s detailed portrayal makes the character feel convincing rather than merely imitative. Felicity Jones is equally compelling as Jane, conveying her affection, determination, frustration, and exhaustion through subtle expressions and emotional restraint. The supporting cast also contributes to the film’s overall impact. It is hardly surprising that the performances received significant recognition.

The makeup and styling are equally effective without becoming excessive. The characters’ appearances reflect the different periods of their lives, helping the passage of time feel natural. The music and sound effects complement the emotional tone of each scene, while the camera movements, transitions, and color composition help establish the atmosphere. These elements work together without distracting from the story or the people at its center.

Overall, The Theory of Everything is a successful adaptation that brings an extraordinary life story to the screen with sensitivity and emotional depth. It balances Stephen’s scientific achievements with the personal struggles that shaped his relationship with Jane. For me, its greatest strength lies in its ability to make a story about a celebrated scientist feel deeply human. Behind the public image of a brilliant mind are people who experience exhaustion, uncertainty, love, disappointment, and the difficult process of letting go.

The scene that left the strongest impression on me is the moment Jane realizes that her relationship with Stephen is no longer what it once was, particularly after Elaine enters his life. Jane looks back on the years they have shared, remembering that Stephen was initially expected to live for only two years after his diagnosis. They have endured so much together, and Jane has made countless sacrifices along the way. Yet she eventually decides to let go, despite how painful that decision must be.

I admit that Stephen’s decision to fall in love with Elaine can feel disappointing, especially when considered from Jane’s perspective. Reading his reported statement elsewhere, “It's wonderful – I have married the woman I love,” might even make it seem as though his feelings for Jane meant less to him. But I do not think we can judge their relationship so simply. Both Stephen and Jane faced immense difficulties, and neither could remain untouched by the demands of the life they had built together. Their relationship changed, and perhaps separating was the best decision they could make for themselves at that point in their lives. The fact that they were still able to maintain a friendship afterward suggests that the end of their marriage did not erase the meaning of their shared years.

Their story reminds me that love is not always about staying together forever. Sometimes, people can love one another deeply and still reach a point where they need to move in different directions. The sacrifices made within a relationship deserve recognition, but they do not necessarily mean that either person must remain in a situation that no longer works for them. Understanding this does not make separation painless; it simply allows us to acknowledge that relationships are more complicated than the labels of success and failure.

One line from the film captures its enduring message: “While there is life, there is hope.” It speaks to Stephen’s determination to keep living and working despite his diagnosis, but it can also apply to the many ways people rebuild their lives after hardship. Hope does not always mean that everything will return to how it was. Sometimes, it means finding a way forward when the life we once imagined is no longer possible.

With its moving story, outstanding performances, and thoughtful portrayal of love, sacrifice, and resilience, The Theory of Everything is undoubtedly a must-watch for me. It is not simply a film about a brilliant scientist or a marriage tested by illness. It is also a reminder that even extraordinary people cannot escape the complicated realities of being human.

When life changes in ways we never expected, can we accept that love may take different forms over time—and still find hope in the life that remains?

My Rating: 10/10 — Must Watch

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments