Lost Girls (2020) Review: A Mother’s Fight Against a System That Refused to Listen

 

Lost Girls (2020)

Lost Girls | 2020 | 1h 35m
Genre: True Crime / Whodunnit / Crime / Drama / Mystery / Thriller | Country: US
Director: Liz Garbus | Writers: Michael Werwie, Robert Kolker
Cast: Amy Ryan, Thomasin McKenzie, Gabriel Byrne
IMDB: 6.2
My Rate: 8/10

The police not responding properly to her report forces Mari to take matters into her own hands to search for the whereabouts of her daughter. Especially when several other female bodies are found around Long Island, prompting Mari to conduct a deeper investigation.

Warning:

Contains strong language


What would you do if your child disappeared and the people responsible for finding her treated your fear as an inconvenience? For some parents, the nightmare is not only losing a child but also having to convince others that their child deserves to be found. Lost Girls (2020), a crime drama directed by Liz Garbus, tells the story of a mother who refuses to let her missing daughter become another forgotten name, even when the authorities seem unwilling to take her seriously.

Mari Gilbert (Amy Ryan) is preparing to welcome her eldest daughter, Shannan, home, alongside her other daughters, Sherre (Thomasin McKenzie) and Sarra (Oona Laurence). When Shannan fails to arrive, Mari initially assumes her daughter has other plans. But after receiving a phone call from a stranger asking about Shannan, learning that Sherre cannot reach her, and hearing from Shannan’s boyfriend, Mari begins to fear that something is wrong.

Mari reports her daughter missing, only to encounter an inadequate response from the police. Her frustration grows when four bodies are discovered near the area where Shannan disappeared, although Shannan is not among them. Despite her initial reluctance to connect with the other victims’ families, Mari eventually joins forces with them to draw public and media attention to the case. Her search becomes a fight not only for Shannan but also for the other women whose disappearances and deaths risk being overlooked.

Based on Robert Kolker’s nonfiction book Lost Girls: An Unsolved American Mystery, the film draws from the real, unresolved Long Island serial murder case in New York. Rather than attempting to identify a culprit or construct an elaborate investigation, it focuses on the victims’ families, the pain of uncertainty, and the prejudice surrounding the women who disappeared. The film also exposes the consequences of institutional indifference, showing how assumptions about a person’s lifestyle or background can influence whether their suffering is taken seriously.

This is what makes Mari’s struggle so compelling. Her anger is not simply the reaction of a frightened mother; it grows from repeatedly asking for help and feeling that nobody is listening. Each dismissive response deepens her frustration, while every new discovery forces her to confront the possibility that Shannan may never come home. The mystery itself remains important, but the emotional conflict is what drives the story.

Mari is also haunted by her own past. As details emerge about her decision to leave Shannan at a foster home, her search becomes entangled with guilt and regret. She is not portrayed as a flawless mother, and her circumstances are not presented as simple. Instead, the film shows how a person can carry painful memories while desperately trying to do something meaningful in the present. Her determination to find Shannan becomes inseparable from her wish to make peace with the choices she once made.

One of the film’s most painful scenes occurs when Mari cries alone in her car after Sherre learns that she left Shannan at a foster home. At the same time, the police decide to remove Shannan from the search connected to the bodies discovered on Long Island. Mari is overwhelmed by the fear of losing her daughter, the guilt of believing she may have failed her, and the frustration of watching the authorities move on before she has answers. The scene makes her grief feel painfully human, particularly because she is forced to carry so many emotions without knowing how her story will end.

Her experience also invites us to reconsider how quickly we judge other parents. Raising a child alone can mean making difficult decisions without enough support, while living with the consequences long after those decisions have been made. From the outside, it is easy to criticize a parent whose choices we do not understand. But we rarely know the full circumstances behind someone else’s life, the options they had, or the pressures they were facing. Understanding does not mean approving every decision; it means recognizing that judgment without context can be cruel.

The film’s portrayal of the police may frustrate viewers who expect professionalism and competence from those responsible for protecting the public. Yet that frustration serves a purpose. When a missing-person report is met with indifference, the family is left to fight two battles at once: searching for their loved one and persuading the authorities that the search matters. The film’s criticism is especially disturbing because it highlights how prejudice can determine whose disappearance receives attention and whose suffering is dismissed.

One limitation is that Shannan and the other victims are not developed in much depth as individuals. We learn relatively little about their personalities and inner lives, and the investigative side of the mystery receives less attention than the families’ emotional struggles. Viewers looking for a detailed procedural thriller or a compelling sequence of investigative breakthroughs may find this approach less satisfying. However, the emphasis on the families allows the film to keep its attention on the human cost of an unresolved case.

Amy Ryan delivers a moving performance as Mari, conveying anger, grief, desperation, and regret without losing the character’s determination. Thomasin McKenzie and Oona Laurence also contribute effectively as Sherre and Sarra, while the supporting cast helps ground the story. The opening, which shows Shannan running as a car follows her, establishes an unsettling atmosphere, and the cinematography and transitions support the gradual unfolding of events. The music is particularly affecting in the scene where Mari cries in her car, with a raw female vocal adding to the sense of helplessness.

The film’s ending is sad, but its inclusion of real people connected to the case makes the conclusion especially affecting. It brings the story back to the lives behind the headlines and reminds viewers that an unresolved case is not merely a mystery waiting for an answer. It is an ongoing wound for those left behind. Mari’s determination also brings a degree of change, including a shift in how Detective Richard Dormer responds to her efforts.

The line, “They say not knowing is worse than knowing, but I'm not sure,” captures the cruelty of uncertainty. Knowing the truth can bring its own devastation, but not knowing leaves room for fear, hope, guilt, and endless possibilities to compete inside the mind. For a parent searching for a missing child, every unanswered question can become another burden to carry.

Overall, Lost Girls is worth watching, especially for viewers interested in crime dramas based on real events. It may not offer the investigative depth of a conventional mystery, but its emotional focus makes the story meaningful. More than anything, it challenges us to think about how society treats people whose lives do not fit its expectations. Before deciding that someone is undeserving of sympathy, can we honestly say we understand the life they have lived—or are we simply judging the parts of their story we can see?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments