The
Platform 2 (Original title: El hoyo 2) | 2024 | 1h 39m
Genre:
Dystopian Sci-Fi/Horror/Sci-Fi/Thriller | Country: Spain
Director:
Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia | Writers: Galder Gaztelu-Urrutia, Pedro Rivero, David
Desola
Cast:
Milena Smit, Hovik Keuchkerian, Natalia Tena
IMDB:
4.9
My
Rate: 7/10
Perempuan chooses to stay in the Vertical Self-Management Center to calm herself after the events that befell her, as do other participants who live there for various reasons. Everything runs smoothly before a dispute arises between the barbarians and the loyalists who act arbitrarily.
Warning:
Contains
scenes of violence, nudity, and strong language.
What
happens when people enter a place to escape their past, only to find themselves
trapped in a system that forces them to confront another kind of suffering? The
Platform 2 (2024), a prequel to The Platform (2019), explores this
question through a more action-driven story filled with brutal violence,
rebellion, and disturbing mysteries. Although it expands the world of the first
film, it does not necessarily bring viewers closer to understanding it.
The
story follows Perempuan (Milena Smit), an artist who voluntarily enters the
Vertical Self-Management Center to find peace after a traumatic incident
involving her boyfriend. During her exhibition, his child dies, leaving
Perempuan struggling to process what happened. Hoping that time away will help
her think clearly, she begins her stay in the institution, where she shares
Level 24 with Zamiatin (Hovik Keuchkerian), a large man who claims to be a
professor.
Zamiatin
has difficulty controlling his emotions, particularly when he discovers that
people on the levels above have eaten his food. Inside the institution, each
participant is allowed to eat only the food they selected before entering. The
rule seems straightforward, but when survival becomes the priority, even a
seemingly reasonable system can become a source of conflict.
The
situation grows more complicated when a Barbarian causes chaos, resulting in
the deaths of people on Level 23. One of the survivors asks Perempuan and
Zamiatin to throw away the food that should have belonged to the deceased.
Zamiatin, however, cannot bring himself to waste it and secretly eats some of
it. A month later, they wake up on a lower level, and Zamiatin's violation has
come to the attention of Dagin Babi (Óscar Jaenada), a man known as the Messiah
who commands the Loyalists. Knowing that he will be punished, Zamiatin makes an
extreme decision: he sets himself on fire to prevent Perempuan from suffering
the consequences of his actions.
Perempuan
eventually moves to Level 51, where she meets Sahabat, another participant who
has suffered at the hands of Dagin Babi and lost a hand because of him.
Learning about this injustice deepens Perempuan's dissatisfaction with the
institution's supposed leadership. She begins to challenge its rules and
encourages the Barbarians to rebel. But opposing an oppressive system is not
without consequences, and Perempuan soon finds herself in serious trouble. Can
she survive the institution and find the peace she came looking for?
As a
prequel, The Platform 2 can be watched without having seen the first
film because its central conflict follows a different path. However, I would
still recommend watching The Platform (2019) first, especially if you
want to understand the significance of the ending. The connection between the
two films becomes more meaningful when their stories are viewed together, even
if the sequel does not resolve all the questions raised by its predecessor.
One
of the most noticeable differences is the way the two films approach their
tension. The first The Platform feels more artistic and emotionally
driven, particularly through Goreng's psychological struggles and gradual
transformation. The Platform 2, by comparison, relies more heavily on
physical confrontations, brutal violence, and sadistic scenes. It offers plenty
of tension, but the emotional turbulence that made the first film so compelling
is less prominent here.
That
does not mean the prequel fails in every respect. In fact, I think it
establishes its narrative foundations more effectively in certain areas.
Instead of focusing almost entirely on its main character, it gives several
other participants meaningful backstories. Their experiences and interactions
make the world feel more populated and help strengthen the conflicts that
develop throughout the story.
The
institution's rules are also explained more clearly. Participants can eat only
the food they requested before entering, which provides a more concrete basis
for the disputes over food and survival. This rule makes the system easier to
understand, even if its underlying purpose remains questionable. Unfortunately,
the explanation only leads to another question: who created these rules in the
first place?
Dagin
Babi appears to hold considerable authority, almost as if he were the
institution's leader. Yet the film never adequately explains how he gained that
position or what gives him the power to impose his own interpretation of the
rules. The organization itself remains a mystery, just as it did in the first
film. We still do not know where it originated or how people learn about its
existence and decide to enter it.
The
central conflict emerges from growing dissatisfaction with Dagin Babi's
leadership. The Barbarians refuse to obey the established rules, while the
Loyalists defend the system and its self-appointed Messiah. The tension
escalates when Perempuan witnesses the injustice committed under Dagin Babi's
authority. Her frustration eventually drives her to encourage the Barbarians to
revolt.
This
conflict gives The Platform 2 a distinct identity rather than simply
repeating the first film's story. Its focus on rebellion, obedience, and
competing interpretations of what is right creates an engaging foundation. The
problem is that the film's resolution does not fully deliver on the potential
of these ideas.
The
philosophy that made the first film so powerful becomes less clear when both
stories are considered together. Instead of providing a satisfying explanation
of the institution and its purpose, the prequel introduces even more unanswered
questions. Perempuan does experience character development, however, gradually
coming to terms with her past. Her journey suggests that finding peace may
require more than escaping a painful experience; sometimes, it means
confronting the things we have been trying to leave behind.
One
particularly confusing element involves the children shown playing on a
pyramid-shaped slide. The film does not clearly explain who these children are,
how they ended up in the institution, or why they are there. Their presence
becomes even more significant when the story reveals that the organization
deliberately places children on Level 333—not necessarily the same child each
time.
As
the ending unfolds, Perempuan and others after her appear to repeat the act of
rescuing a child from Level 333. This development raises questions that the
film never answers. How can children survive on that level when people on the
levels above them are already struggling to obtain food? Do they survive by
eating the bodies thrown into the pit? Do they remain on the same level instead
of being moved each month? And how long must they endure those conditions
before someone finally comes to rescue them?
These
are not minor details. The children's presence seems central to the larger
mystery, yet the film leaves their circumstances largely unexplained. Rather
than making the institution's purpose clearer, this storyline makes it more
difficult to understand what is actually happening.
The
fate of Goreng is another issue I hoped the prequel would clarify. The ending
connects Perempuan and other characters to the same mysterious place beneath
Level 333 where Goreng ends up in the first film. Yet we still do not know what
happens there or how the people who reach it survive. Are they forced to eat
the bodies discarded into the seemingly bottomless pit? A scene showing people
rushing toward a falling corpse makes this possibility difficult to ignore, but
the film does not provide a definitive answer.
The
appearance of Trimagasi also serves as a bridge between the prequel and the
original film, reminding us of his importance in Goreng's story. While this
connection may interest viewers familiar with the first installment, it also
creates new questions about how these characters' paths intersect and what the
events at Level 333 ultimately mean. For a prequel that might have been
expected to fill in the gaps, the result feels frustratingly incomplete.
Despite
these narrative weaknesses, the performances are generally good. The actors
convey their characters' emotions convincingly, especially Milena Smit as
Perempuan. The camera movements and framing also work well, particularly when
the film draws attention to the details of its more disturbing scenes. One
example is the moment Perempuan's hand is cut off, with the blood effects
making the violence feel particularly graphic. The music and sound effects
complement the scenes effectively, helping maintain the tension throughout the
film.
As
in the first installment, some character names may sound unusual to Indonesian
viewers because they are ordinary Indonesian words with meanings that are not
typically used as personal names. Perempuan means “woman,” Sahabat means
“friend” or “best friend,” and Dagin Babi is apparently a reference to “pork.”
These names can feel strange when heard in a Spanish film, even if their
unusual nature also adds an unexpected layer of absurdity to an already surreal
setting.
My
most memorable scene is Zamiatin's decision to burn himself alive to protect
Perempuan. He has made a mistake by eating food that belonged to deceased
participants, and Dagin Babi's followers are looking for him so he can be
punished. Rather than allow Perempuan, who is not responsible for his actions,
to suffer alongside him, Zamiatin chooses to take the consequences upon
himself.
The
act is extreme and tragic, but what stays with me is his willingness to
acknowledge his mistake and accept responsibility for it. He does not try to
shift the blame onto someone else. More importantly, he refuses to let an
innocent person bear the cost of his wrongdoing. In a place where people are
often driven by self-preservation, his decision reveals a different kind of
courage: the willingness to take responsibility for the harm one has caused and
to protect someone else from its consequences.
The
line that stands out to me is, “We are prisoners of ourselves, there is no
escape.” It captures one of the film's central ideas, although the story itself
leaves plenty of room for interpretation. The institution may imprison its
participants physically, but their fears, guilt, beliefs, and choices can
become prisons of their own. Sometimes, even when we have the opportunity to
change our circumstances, we remain trapped by the things we cannot accept
about ourselves.
Overall,
The Platform 2 is still worth watching, particularly for viewers who
enjoyed the first film and want to explore more of its disturbing world. It
offers stronger character backstories, a different central conflict, intense
action, and effective performances. However, the success of its predecessor
also creates a difficult burden for the prequel to carry. Rather than answering
the questions left behind by The Platform (2019), it introduces a new
collection of mysteries and leaves several important plot elements
underdeveloped.
The
cliffhanger ending may encourage viewers to keep thinking about the story, but
it also leaves the experience less satisfying than it could have been. The film
has interesting ideas about authority, obedience, rebellion, guilt, and
survival, yet it does not bring all those ideas together in a sufficiently
clear resolution.
Perhaps
that is the most frustrating part of The Platform 2: it makes us want to
understand the system more deeply, but offers few answers about who created it,
who benefits from it, or why it continues to exist. And that question extends
beyond the fictional institution. When we live within systems whose rules we
did not create, how often do we question who holds the power, why those rules
exist, and whether following them is truly the same as doing what is right?
Rating:
7/10 — Worth Watching
(Aluna
Uwie)
Previously
published on Alunauwie.com
This
article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English
for international readers.

0 Comments