Enola Holmes (2020) Review: A Clever Mystery About a Girl Who Refuses to Follow Society’s Rules

 

Enola Holmes (2020) Movie Review

Enola Holmes | 2020 | 2h 3m
Genre: Cozy Mystery / Dark Comedy / Teen Adventure / Teen Drama / Whodunnit / Adventure / Crime / Drama / Mystery
Country: UK-US
Director: Harry Bradbeer
Writers: Jack Thorne, Nancy Springer, Arthur Conan Doyle
Cast: Millie Bobby Brown, Henry Cavill, Sam Claflin
IMDB: 6.6
My Rating: 9/10

Enola tries to find the whereabouts of her mother, who suddenly disappears, by embarking on a thrilling adventure, especially when she must avoid being found by her brother who wants to send her to boarding school, and when she accidentally gets caught in a murder conspiracy involving Tewkesbury.

Warning:

Contains scenes of violence and strong language.


What if being a respectable woman meant giving up your freedom to think, speak, and decide what kind of life you wanted? Enola Holmes (2020), directed by Harry Bradbeer, explores this question through a young woman who refuses to let society dictate her future. Blending mystery, adventure, family drama, and humor, the film offers an entertaining detective story while reminding us that independence begins with the courage to think for ourselves.

Enola (Millie Bobby Brown) grows up with her mother, Eudoria (Helena Bonham Carter), after the death of her father and the departure of her two older brothers, Sherlock (Henry Cavill) and Mycroft (Sam Claflin). On her sixteenth birthday, however, her mother suddenly disappears. Sherlock and Mycroft return home, but their arrival brings little comfort. Mycroft believes Enola's unconventional behavior makes her unsuitable for a respectable young woman and decides to send her to a boarding school to learn proper manners, while Sherlock recognizes her intelligence but cannot do much because Mycroft has legal custody of her.

Refusing to surrender her freedom, Enola follows clues hidden in her mother's gifts and discovers money that allows her to escape. Her journey to find Eudoria takes an unexpected turn when she encounters Tewkesbury, a young marquess fleeing from a dangerous assassin. After helping him escape, Enola accompanies him to London, where they eventually go their separate ways. She resumes her search for her mother, disguising herself to evade the people Mycroft has sent after her. Yet her encounter with the assassin forces her to investigate a larger conspiracy that threatens Tewkesbury's life. Can Enola find her mother and uncover the truth before it is too late?

Enola Holmes is adapted from Nancy Springer's The Enola Holmes Mysteries, specifically the first book, The Case of the Missing Marquess. Some Sherlock Holmes fans may find the portrayal of the famous detective different from what they expect. However, it is worth remembering that this is Enola's story, not Sherlock's. The film deliberately shifts the spotlight to a younger character whose intelligence, personality, and experiences shape the narrative. The differences in Sherlock's characterization make more sense when we recognize that he is part of Enola's journey rather than its central figure.

And who knew Sherlock Holmes had a younger sister? Well, apparently, I didn't. Haha.

Before watching the film, I expected a serious and potentially exhausting detective story, the kind that might require considerable patience to follow. Instead, I found something much lighter, more playful, and surprisingly engaging. The film still offers mysteries to solve, but it presents them in a way that feels accessible without losing its charm. It is not simply about discovering clues and identifying the culprit; it is also about understanding the people behind the mysteries and the choices that shape their lives.

One of the film's most distinctive storytelling techniques is Enola's habit of looking directly into the camera and speaking to the audience. This fourth-wall-breaking approach makes viewers feel as though they are accompanying her on the adventure. Rather than observing her from a distance, we become her confidants, sharing her discoveries and reactions along the way. The technique is used in a balanced way, making the story feel personal without becoming tiresome.

For viewers who love challenging mysteries, however, the film may feel a little too straightforward. Some clues and riddles are explained so clearly that it becomes easy to understand what is happening before the characters finish working through them. The mystery does not always demand the kind of close attention or complicated deduction that seasoned fans might expect. Even so, the presentation of the clues remains entertaining, and the story's appeal extends beyond the puzzle itself.

The narrative foundation is particularly effective. We learn about Enola's family history, her unusual upbringing, and the mysterious aspects of her mother's life before the central conflict fully unfolds. Her mother's disappearance brings the family back together, but it also exposes the differences between the siblings. These differences become the basis for both the external conflict and the emotional struggles that develop throughout the film.

Enola's problems are not limited to the mystery she is trying to solve. She also struggles with the feeling that her family does not truly want her. Her mother has disappeared, Mycroft wants to send her away, and Sherlock seems unable or unwilling to protect her. Mycroft, meanwhile, believes he has a responsibility to preserve the family's reputation and ensure that Enola becomes a respectable woman. Sherlock faces his own uncertainty as he begins to recognize his sister's abilities and independence. These competing perspectives make the family dynamic more interesting than a simple conflict between a clever girl and two unreasonable brothers.

Beyond its mystery, the film explores feminism and political manipulation. Women are expected to become wives, behave respectably, and avoid anything society considers improper or embarrassing. Enola, Eudoria, and several other women challenge these expectations in different ways, refusing to accept that their lives must be determined by the roles assigned to them. Their resistance gives the adventure a broader meaning: the freedom to choose one's future is not merely a personal privilege but something that society often makes difficult for women to claim.

The political dimension is also woven into Tewkesbury's predicament. His life is threatened because his voice and position could affect a larger political struggle. His personal danger therefore becomes part of a conflict over who gets to influence the future. By connecting the mystery to political interests and social expectations, the film creates a story that is about more than one missing mother or one endangered young man.

The resolution brings these threads together effectively. The main mysteries are addressed, and the characters show meaningful development. Enola and Tewkesbury become more mature through their experiences, while Sherlock and Mycroft begin to reconsider their views of their younger sister. The revelation surrounding Eudoria's disappearance also gives the central family conflict a satisfying sense of closure. Rather than relying solely on a final revelation, the film allows its characters to change in ways that make their journeys feel worthwhile.

Millie Bobby Brown delivers a particularly engaging performance as Enola. She captures the character's intelligence, curiosity, humor, and determination without making her feel one-dimensional. Her performance earned her the Favorite Movie Actress award at the 2021 Kids' Choice Awards and the Youth in Film – Female award from the Las Vegas Film Critics Society Awards, as noted in the film's reception. The supporting cast also contributes to the story, including characters with relatively limited screen time whose appearances still influence the direction of the plot.

The technical presentation complements the storytelling. The cinematography captures details that become relevant to the mystery, while the transitions and editing keep the scenes flowing smoothly. The costumes suit the period setting without feeling excessive, and the music and sound effects help establish the mood of each sequence. Together, these elements give the film a distinctive visual identity while allowing the story and characters to remain at the center.

Overall, Enola Holmes is an engaging film that balances mystery, action, humor, and family drama. Its puzzles may not be especially challenging for devoted mystery enthusiasts, but its accessible storytelling and meaningful themes make it enjoyable for a wider audience. More importantly, it presents independence not as a rejection of family or tradition for its own sake, but as the ability to discover who you are and decide what kind of life you want to lead.

My most memorable scene is when Sherlock visits Enola at the boarding school and brings her a childhood toy. He explains that their mother kept it because she always considered Enola an extraordinary child. Through this small gesture, Sherlock helps Enola understand that her mother's disappearance does not necessarily mean she stopped loving her.

The scene is touching because Enola has been struggling with the possibility that she was abandoned. Her brothers' apparent indifference only reinforces that fear, leaving her to question whether she matters to the people she loves. Sherlock's words offer her a little reassurance, allowing her to see that love is not always as easy to recognize as we might wish.

Sometimes, when someone we love disappears from our lives or behaves in a way we cannot understand, we begin to question our own worth. We may assume that their absence means we were never important to them, even when we do not know the full story. This does not mean every absence should be excused, but it reminds us that our fears are not always the same as the truth. A small act of reassurance can help someone feel seen again, especially when they have spent a long time believing they were unwanted.

The memorable line, “Our future is up to us,” captures the spirit of Enola's journey. We cannot always control the circumstances into which we are born, the expectations placed upon us, or the choices other people make. But we can decide whether to let those circumstances define us. Enola's story encourages us to question the rules we have inherited and to recognize that being different does not automatically mean being wrong.

I rate Enola Holmes 9/10 and consider it a must-watch. With a charming lead performance, an engaging mystery, thoughtful family drama, and a meaningful exploration of women's independence, the film offers much more than a detective adventure. Its happy ending leaves us with a hopeful reminder that we do not have to follow the path others have chosen for us. If our future is truly ours to shape, are we brave enough to choose a life that reflects who we really are rather than who the world expects us to be?

(Aluna Uwie)

Previously published on Alunauwie.com

This article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English for international readers.

 

Post a Comment

0 Comments