The
Swan | 2023 | 17m
Genre:
Comedy/Drama/Short | Country: US
Director:
Wes Anderson | Writers: Roald Dahl, Wes Anderson
Cast:
Rupert Friend, Ralph Fiennes, Asa Jennings
IMDB:
6.7
My
Rate: 9/10
Peter experiences bullying from Ernie and his friend, where Peter cannot do anything because of Ernie’s threat with a gun. The gun Ernie received as a birthday present ends up ruining someone else’s life.
Warning:
Scenes of violenceHow
cruel can a child become when given the power to hurt others, and how much
courage does it take to resist that cruelty when there seems to be no way out? The
Swan (2023), a 17-minute short film directed by Wes Anderson and adapted
from a short story by Roald Dahl, explores these questions through a disturbing
tale of bullying, fear, and a boy who refuses to surrender what he believes is
worth protecting. As the second short film in Anderson’s collection of Dahl
adaptations, following The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar (2023), it
offers a moving story that lingers long after the final scene.
The
story begins when Ernie receives a gun as a birthday present. Excited by his
new possession, he and his friend set out to shoot birds. During their outing,
they encounter Peter, a boy who is observing birds. Instead of leaving him
alone, the two bullies decide to torment him. Armed with a weapon, Ernie holds
power over Peter, who has little chance of defending himself. Their cruelty
escalates when they tie Peter to a railway track. Although he survives, the
ordeal does not end there. They later kill a swan, cut off its wings, and
attach them to Peter’s arms. Eventually, Peter is forced to climb a tree while
Ernie prepares to shoot him from a distance. With his life in danger, the
question becomes whether Peter can survive the violence inflicted upon him.
What
makes The Swan particularly moving is that Peter does not seem genuinely
afraid of his tormentors, even when he is placed in terrifying situations. His
physical vulnerability does not erase his inner resolve. The film presents
bullying as more than a conflict between children; it shows what happens when
cruelty is empowered by the possession of a weapon and the absence of
meaningful consequences. A gift intended to bring excitement to a birthday
becomes an instrument of terror, revealing how something that appears harmless
in one person's hands can become destructive in another's.
Like
The Wonderful Story of Henry Sugar, this film relies heavily on
narration to tell its story. However, the narrator here plays a particularly
significant role because he represents the adult version of the character whose
childhood experiences are being recounted. His storytelling feels like an
attempt to revisit an old wound, bringing buried memories back to the surface.
Through his voice, the events gain an emotional depth that might have been
difficult to achieve through visuals alone. The narration does not simply
explain what happens; it makes the story feel like a painful memory that has
never entirely faded.
The
visual presentation also deserves attention. Rather than showing every act of
bullying explicitly, the film often leaves parts of the violence to the
audience's imagination. This approach encourages viewers to experience the
events from Peter's perspective, filling in the gaps themselves and imagining
the fear and helplessness he might feel. It is an artistic choice that can be
effective, although it may not appeal to everyone. Some viewers prefer a
director to translate the action into clear visual scenes rather than leave
them to construct those images mentally. Nevertheless, the restrained depiction
of violence gives the story a disturbing quality without relying entirely on
graphic imagery.
Compared
with the previous film in the collection, The Swan uses fewer locations.
Yet the camera work and symmetrical compositions help prevent the setting from
feeling monotonous. The variety of shots also keeps the narrative visually
engaging. Anderson's distinctive approach makes the film feel carefully arranged,
with the visual style supporting rather than overwhelming the story.
The
narrative itself is built on a solid foundation. The important characters and
circumstances are introduced clearly, including how Ernie obtains his gun, how
the boys encounter Peter, and who Peter is. These details help establish the
circumstances that lead to the central conflict. The tension then develops
systematically through a series of increasingly disturbing incidents: Peter is
tied to the railway track, the swan is killed and its wings are attached to
him, and the bullying eventually reaches its most dangerous point when Ernie
prepares to shoot him. Each event raises the stakes, allowing the audience to
feel the growing threat to Peter's life.
One
of the most memorable scenes occurs when Peter is ordered to retrieve the dead
swan. The bullies ask him about the swan's eggs, but Peter chooses to lie and
conceal their whereabouts. He knows that protecting them could put him at
greater risk, yet he refuses to expose something innocent to further harm. This
small act of resistance reveals a great deal about his character. Even when he
has almost no control over his own circumstances, he still finds a way to make
a choice based on what he believes is right.
Perhaps
this is one of the film's most meaningful ideas: courage does not always look
like fighting back. Sometimes, it means refusing to cooperate with cruelty,
even when doing so comes at a personal cost. Many of us have faced moments when
doing the right thing seemed likely to bring trouble upon ourselves. Protecting
someone vulnerable, speaking up against unfairness, or refusing to participate
in another person's humiliation can all carry risks. But does the possibility
of suffering automatically make the right decision the wrong one? Peter's
actions suggest otherwise. A good intention does not guarantee a painless
outcome, but it can still give our choices meaning.
The
film's conclusion is beautifully executed and deeply heartbreaking, especially
because of Peter's mother's dialogue. Her words feel painfully relatable to
parents whose children become victims of bullying. There is something
particularly devastating about seeing a child suffer while knowing that the
people who should protect children do not always understand the full extent of
their pain. The ending leaves a lasting emotional impact, although the film
does not clearly reveal what eventually happens to the bullies. That unresolved
detail may leave some viewers wanting a greater sense of accountability or
closure.
The
performances are excellent despite the limited facial expressions displayed by
the actors. The narrator's intonation brings the story to life, while the music
and sound effects strengthen its atmosphere without feeling out of place.
Together, these elements create a film in which storytelling, sound, and
carefully composed images work in harmony. Its strength lies less in showing
everything directly than in allowing the audience to feel the weight of what
happens.
One
line captures the spirit of the story particularly well: “Nothing, neither pain
nor torture nor threat of death, will cause them to give up.” It expresses a
form of determination that goes beyond physical strength. Yet the film also
invites us to consider the painful circumstances in which such determination
becomes necessary. No child should have to demonstrate extraordinary courage
simply to survive the cruelty of others.
I
rate The Swan (2023) 9/10 and consider it a must-watch, particularly for
viewers who appreciate artistic filmmaking and narratives that take precedence
over explicit visual spectacle. Its disturbing subject matter, restrained
presentation, strong narration, and emotionally powerful conclusion make it a
memorable short film. However, viewers should be aware that it contains scenes
of violence and bullying. Ultimately, The Swan reminds us that even when
we cannot control the cruelty directed at us, we may still have the power to
decide what we will protect and what we refuse to become. If doing the right
thing means risking something precious to ourselves, would we still have the
courage to choose it?
(Aluna
Uwie)
Previously
published on Alunauwie.com
This
article was originally written in Indonesian and has been adapted into English
for international readers.

0 Comments